A Farewell to Alms

Gregory Clark

出版时间

2007-08-13

ISBN

9780691121352

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
Why are some parts of the world so rich and others so poor? Why did the Industrial Revolution--and the unprecedented economic growth that came with it--occur in eighteenth-century England, and not at some other time, or in some other place? Why didn't industrialization make the whole world rich--and why did it make large parts of the world even poorer? In A Farewell to Alms, Gregory Clark tackles these profound questions and suggests a new and provocative way in which culture--not exploitation, geography, or resources--explains the wealth, and the poverty, of nations.

Countering the prevailing theory that the Industrial Revolution was sparked by the sudden development of stable political, legal, and economic institutions in seventeenth-century Europe, Clark shows that such institutions existed long before industrialization. He argues instead that these institutions gradually led to deep cultural changes by encouraging people to abandon hunter-gatherer instincts-violence, impatience, and economy of effort-and adopt economic habits-hard work, rationality, and education.

The problem, Clark says, is that only societies that have long histories of settlement and security seem to develop the cultural characteristics and effective workforces that enable economic growth. For the many societies that have not enjoyed long periods of stability, industrialization has not been a blessing. Clark also dissects the notion, championed by Jared Diamond in Guns, Germs, and Steel, that natural endowments such as geography account for differences in the wealth of nations.

A brilliant and sobering challenge to the idea that poor societies can be economically developed through outside intervention, A Farewell to Alms may change the way global economic history is understood.

AI导读
核心看点
  • 提出文化而非地理决定国家贫富
  • 详解工业革命前马尔萨斯陷阱机制
  • 论证自然选择塑造现代经济行为
适合谁读
  • 对经济史与人类发展感兴趣者
  • 具备经济学基础的专业读者
  • 喜欢挑战传统历史观的读者
读前提醒
  • 前部分数据详实,后部分理论激进
  • 部分观点争议大,需批判性阅读
  • 建议配合作者视频课程辅助理解
读者共识
  • 前半部实证分析精彩,后半部稍弱
  • 观点大胆新颖,但证据链存争议
  • 数据丰富但阅读体验略显枯燥

本导读基于书籍简介、目录、原文摘录、短评和书评生成,不等同于全文精读。

精彩摘录
  • "经济史带来的最后一个出人意料的现象就是,物质的极大丰富、儿童死亡率的降低、成人寿命周期的延长以及收入分配不均现象的减少并没有使我们变得比狩猎一采集时期的祖先们更快乐。高收入深刻改变了现代发达社会里人们的生活方式。但财富并没有带来快乐。这就是为什么虽然如今富国和穷国之间的收入差距十分巨大,但穷国自我报告的幸福感却只比富国稍微低一点的原因,尽管穷国的国民可以通过电视这种媒介亲身了解到富国人们的生活。"
  • "In contrast in England the majority of people, until quite close to 1800, lived in dwellings with beaten earth floors covered by rushes that were only infrequently renewed. Into these rushes went deposits of waste food, urine, and spit. Indeed the effluvium deposited on floors from ordinary househol"
  • "中国和日本之所以在同样的道路上没有英国发展的快,仅仅是因为在这两个国家夫人的生育能力只比总人口生育水平略高一点"
  • "尽管人们对于工业革命的通常印象是,它将原本快乐的农民变成了工厂里任人剥削的奴隶,但事实上,这种情景早在工业革命发生之前就出现了。"
用户评论
A stirring book with bold pronouncement and weak evidence.
第一部分五星,对工业革命前马尔萨斯图景的极佳描绘,数据工作独到精妙,第二部分四星,数据价值同样高,分析稍欠,对竞争理论的拒斥有些草率,第三部分三星,理论相当进取,但比较单薄
物竞天择经济发展学
数据太多轶闻太少,读起来还是很无趣的,不过有趣的观点真的挺多。
Truly insightful and rewarding. The intellectual honesty and seriousness demonstrated in this book is breathtaking. Deserves a reread and note taking.
虎头蛇尾 前面可以四星
作者用了大半本书的章节分析了前工业时代的马尔萨斯陷阱,但对于工业革命经济转型的原因分析却依然不够solid,虎头蛇尾感
Though it is a book of economic history, the title is reminiscent of Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms.
工业革命和大分流大概是经济史里最重要的问题,只是现在距离经济史学家们达成共识似乎越来越远,Clark的基因论、Allen的工资论、Joel Mokyr要讲启蒙文化,大龙是制度二分,彭慕兰重视燃料新大陆,还有什么欧洲婚姻制度、近代财政国家等等等等,迫切需要一个统一框架研究这个问题😅
A very interesting social Darwinism perspective of economic history.
收藏