书籍介绍
这不是一本教你如何做咨询的技巧手册，而是一面让人不太舒服的镜子。作者以十位来访者的真实困境为切口，把死亡、自由、孤独、虚无这四个无法回避的存在命题，摆到每个正在挣扎的普通人面前。读者反复提到的，不是书中提供了答案，而是它逼你直面那些平时刻意绕开的问题：人会死、要对自己负责、本质孤独、人生或许并无既定意义。有意思的是，许多读者并不买账——有人读完第一个故事便压抑数日，有人嫌后续平淡，也有人不满作者流露的傲慢与
AI导读
核心看点
- 本书收录十个真实心理治疗案例，直面死亡、孤独、自由与无意义四大终极关怀。作者以第一人称视角，毫无保留地展示治疗师在咨询室中的挣扎、困惑与伦理困境，揭示治疗关系并非单向的施救，而是两个真实人类之间的深度相遇与相互影响。
- 亚隆在书中坦诚剖析自身作为治疗师的局限性，包括对患者的嫉妒、无力感及情感卷入。他拒绝扮演全知全能的拯救者，而是与患者共同探索生命困境。这种诚实打破了传统心理治疗的神秘面纱，让读者看到治疗师也是充满人性弱点的普通人，而非高高在上的权威。
- 书中案例深刻探讨爱与治疗的边界，指出浪漫爱情与心理治疗在本质上的不相容性。作者强调，真正的疗愈源于个体对自身生命责任的承担，而非依赖外部救赎。通过直面存在的焦虑，个体才能从逃避走向真实，获得内在的自由与力量，这是全书最核心的伦理与哲学立场。
读者共识
- 读者普遍认为本书情感真挚、文笔优美，亚隆的诚实与脆弱令人动容。许多读者表示，书中对人性黑暗面与光明面的同时呈现，提供了深刻的慰藉与启发。尽管部分案例结局令人沮丧，但作者对生命责任的坚持与对真实连接的渴望，激发了读者对自身生活的反思与勇气，被视为具有极高人文价值的作品。
- 部分读者批评书中缺乏系统性理论指导，认为其内容碎片化，对寻求具体心理干预技巧的人帮助有限。另有观点指出，亚隆的某些立场可能过于理想化或带有精英主义色彩，对普通读者的实际困境缺乏足够共情。然而，多数读者仍肯定其在促进自我认知、理解他人痛苦及反思生命意义方面的独特价值，认为其文学性与思想性远超一般心理学读物。
- 读者共识认为，本书不适合追求速成解决方案或娱乐性阅读的受众。它要求读者具备较高的心理承受力与哲学思考能力，愿意直面生命终极问题。尽管存在争议，但其在心理治疗伦理、人际关系本质及存在主义心理学领域的地位不可动摇。读者普遍建议，在情绪稳定、具备一定心理学基础或哲学素养时阅读，以获得最佳体验与深度理解。
精彩摘录
- "Betty, what's the danger in letting me matter to you? I am not sure. It feels scary, like I'll need you too much. I'm not sure you'll be there for me. I'm going to have to leave California in a year, remember?" A year's a long time. So you avoid me now because you won't always have me? I know it doe"
- "I DO NOT LIKE to work with patients who are in love. Perhaps it is because of envy——I, too, crave enchantment. Perhaps it is because love and psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. The good therapist fights darkness and seeks illumination, while romantic love is sustained by mystery and crumb"
- "My primary clinical assumption- an assumption on which I based my technique- is that basic anxiety emerges from a person's endeavors, conscious and unconscious, to cope with the harsh facts of life, the "givens" of existence. I have found that four givens are particularly relevant to psychtherapy: t"
- "Two beliefs/delusions can afford a sense of safety: the belief in personal specialness; the other, the belief in an ultimate rescuer. The human being either asserts autonomy by heroic self-assertionor seeks safety through fusing with a superior force: that is, one either emerges or merges, separates"
- "in bonded to anxiety, it means that one is responsible for one's own choices, actions, one's own life situation. The crucial first step in therapy is the patient's assumption of responsibility for his or her life predicament."
- "Dave could resist assuming responsibility for his marital problems, he could not resist the immediate data he himself was generating in group therapy."
- "Freedom not only requires us to bear responsibility for our life choices but also posits that change requires an act of will. It is through willing, the mainspring of action, that our freedom is enacted. I see willing as having two stages: a person initiates through wishing and then enacts through d"
- "it refers to the unbridgeable gap between self and others—— note: both interpersonal and intrapersonal. There's no solution to exitential isolation, many friendship or marriage has failed because, instead of relating to, and caring for, one another, one person uses other as a shield against isolatio"
用户评论
Resonating with the truthfulness that seeped through each of these stories. Death, Freedom, Isolation, Meaning - don't we deal with them all
太有趣惹
适合时不时拿出来翻翻
在别人的故事里看到自己。很多人一定最喜欢love‘s executioner这一章，实在太精彩，但我的最爱还是fat lady，藏匿在嬉笑里的脆弱，被作者诚实到令人生畏的笔触赤裸裸地揭露出来。毫无疑问，作者对于女性“不够政治正确”的解读可以说是处处显现，我一开始解读为傲慢，细细想来，也许没有这坦诚的丑陋，这本书也不至于这般动人。
Feeling equally disappointed with the book, and with Yalom.
很适合book club的一本书
Honest, well-structured, equipped with witty titles and well-timed pedagogical messages about psychotherapy.
相比于各种案例，更让我觉得不易的是Irvin对于自身诚实地展现，对肥女的厌恶，展示不很成功的案例等。真的看到了一个成熟的心理医生的担当。
下载
收藏