Gang Leader for a Day - Sudhir Venkatesh, 素德·文卡特斯

Gang Leader for a Day

Sudhir Venkatesh, 素德·文卡特斯

出版社

Penguin Press

出版时间

2008-01-10

ISBN

9781594201509

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
First introduced in Freakonomics , here is the full story of Sudhir Venkatesh, the sociology grad student who infiltrated one of Chicago's most notorious gangs The story of the young sociologist who studied a Chicago crack-dealing gang from the inside captured the world's attention when it was first described in Freakonomics . Gang Leader for a Day is the fascinating full story of how Sudhir Venkatesh managed to gain entrŽe into the gang, what he learned, and how his method revolutionized the academic establishment. When Venkatesh walked into an abandoned building in one of Chicago's most notorious housing projects, he was looking for people to take a multiple-choice survey on urban poverty. A first-year grad student hoping to impress his professors with his boldness, he never imagined that as a result of the assignment he would befriend a gang leader named JT and spend the better part of a decade inside the projects under JT's protection, documenting what he saw there. Over the next seven years, Venkatesh got to know the neighborhood dealers, crackheads, squatters, prostitutes, pimps, activists, cops, organizers, and officials. From his privileged position of unprecedented access, he observed JT and the rest of the gang as they operated their crack-selling business, conducted PR within their community, and rose up or fell within the ranks of the gang's complex organizational structure. In Hollywood-speak, Gang Leader for a Day is The Wire meets Harvard University. It's a brazen, page turning, and fundamentally honest view into the morally ambiguous, highly intricate, often corrupt struggle to survive in what is tantamount to an urban war zone. It is also the story of a complicated friendship between Sudhir and JT-two young and ambitious men a universe apart.
AI导读
核心看点
  • 芝大博士生潜入芝加哥黑帮,记录底层生存实录
  • 从问卷调查到深度民族志,颠覆传统学术范式
  • 揭示毒品经济、性交易与贫困文化的复杂共生
适合谁读
  • 对社会学、人类学及定性研究方法感兴趣的读者
  • 关注美国城市贫困、种族问题及黑帮文化的读者
  • 喜欢纪实文学、田野调查故事及非虚构写作的读者
读前提醒
  • 本书非小说而是田野笔记,部分情节可能引发不适
  • 作者情感介入较深,需辩证看待其学术客观性
  • 中译本质量参差不齐,建议有条件者阅读英文原版
读者共识
  • 故事真实精彩,可读性高,比许多小说更引人入胜
  • 展现了黑帮内部的运作逻辑及底层居民的生存智慧
  • 引发对研究者伦理边界及学术方法局限性的深刻反思

本导读基于书籍简介、目录、原文摘录、短评和书评生成,不等同于全文精读。

精彩摘录
  • "J. T. 开始安排我访谈皮条客。他向我解释说,他向所有在他楼里或者附近工作的皮条客抽税:有的人付房间费,有的人付收入提成,支付形式都是向J. T. 的帮派成员提供免费的女人。当然,如果皮条客们使用空闲公寓作为妓院,那他们就要支付额外的费用;他们甚至要为使用楼梯间或者停车场而支付费用。 访谈皮条客的时候,我还结识了某些住在楼里或在楼里工作的自由接客的性工作者,比如克莱瑞莎。当我请求她帮忙介绍这类女性,以供我做访谈的时候,她说:“哦,我的那些女士们可喜欢被关注了!”在两周之内,我访谈了她们中的二十多个人。 将这类访谈与对皮条客所做的访谈进行比较时,我发现了某种差异。那些由皮条客管理的性工作者们("
  • "妇女们有关生存技巧的列表大大超过了十条。在你的公寓里存着香烟,以便有东西坏掉的时候,可以给擅居者作为修理费用。让你的孩子在楼梯间小便,以避免让妓女们夜间在那里聚集。让帮派们付钱以在你的公寓里藏毒品和现金(她们一致同意,遭逮捕的危险很小)。 然后就是所有用性来交换的资源:从杂货店老板那里来的日用品,住宅局那里取消租金,来自福利局的帮助,警官对服刑亲人的优先对待。妇女们对于把性当作现金使用的解释一致而又实际:要是你的孩子陷入了饥饿的危险,那你就会做任何可以解决问题的事情。当她们在讨论使用身体来获取这些必需品时,表情痛苦。很明显,这不是她们的最优先、甚至也不会是第一百种选择。 “永远要认识在医院里的"
  • "然后普雷斯又说起一件事情,穆切曾经在他二十多岁的时候,和当时大约五十五岁的贝利女士上过床。这一消息让我震惊:穆切真的对一位五十多岁的体格壮硕的女性有吸引力吗?普雷斯解释说,年轻的男性经常和老女人睡在一起,尤其是在冬天,因为不然他们可能就找不到一个温暖安全的地方过夜。还有,一个拥有租约的妇女也可以让她的小男友把毒品和钱藏在她的公寓里,或者甚至将其用为自由出售点。"
  • "有一次,JT问我社会学家对于黑帮和内城贫困的观点。我告诉他,有些社会学家认为存在着一种“贫困文化”——即,穷困黑人不工作,乃是因为他们并不像其他的族群那样真是工作,而这一态度会代代相传。“所以你们想让我为我的工作自豪,却只肯付给我最低工资?”JT反问。"
  • "我靠在的JT车上,因为震惊而战栗。他牢牢抓住我,努力让我平静下来。“这不过是这里的一种方式而已,”他低语道,声音里带着一丝清晰可辨的同情,“有时候你必须要揍一个黑鬼,才能给他一个教训。不要担心,过一阵子你就习惯了。” 我想,不,我不想习惯它。如果我习惯了,那我会变成什么人?我想要让停止殴打,把布拉斯送去医院,但是我的耳朵在轰鸣,而我甚至听不清他在跟我说什么。我的眼睛离不开布拉斯,我觉得我好像在呕吐。 然后JT抓住了我的肩膀,把我转过去,让我不再观看。但是从眼角的余光中,我能够看到有几个住户最终还是过去帮助布拉斯,而那些帮派成员们只是站在一旁,无所事事。JT抱着我,好像要安慰我。我试着把自己的身"
  • "实际上,社会学的领域一直以来就分为两个阵营:定量和统计技术型的研究者,以及经常与某个群体的人们共同生活,并通过直接观察来研究他们的生活的研究者。 第二个阵营通常被称为民族志研究者。"
  • "在他的想像中,除了领袖,他还是个同等程度的慈善家。他骄傲地谈起自己脱离芝加哥市中心的主流销售工作,而返回到这个计划区,并利用他的毒品利润来“帮助其他人”。他是怎么帮助的呢?他强令他所有的属下都必须拿到高中毕业证书,并且远离毒品。他资助一些当地的青少年中心,以购买体育用品和电脑。他愿意把自己的属下借给罗伯特?泰勒的租户领袖们,帮助他们为老年人跑腿,或者揍那些家庭施暴者。甚至可以把他通过销售毒品赚钱的事实说成是好事。他告诉我,毒品经济是“对社区有益的”,因为它可以将瘾君子的钱通过帮派的慈善活动再分配回社区。"
  • "我对帮派与警察的关系感到好奇,但是这很难猜测。帮派成员们在光天化日之下出售毒品,我奇怪为什么没有警察来关掉这些公开的市场。但是我得不到关于这一问题任何实质的回答。总是对这一话题讳莫如深,而在这一街区的绝大多数人则根本都不敢谈论警察——在我看来,甚至更不敢谈论帮派。作为一名成长于那种欢迎警察出现的郊区的人,我觉得这很奇怪。但是显然我还有很多不理解的事情。 如果要准备同其他帮派开战,那黑暗之王也需要召开全体大会。偶尔有时,战争会因为不同帮派的少年成员之间卷入打斗而爆发,然后升级。但是像这样的老大会极力阻止此类冲突,因为它会无端威胁到生意。更为典型的情况是,战争会爆发于当一个帮派试图要占领原本属于另"
作者简介
Sudhir Venkatesh is William B. Ransford Professor of Sociology, and the Committee on Global Thought, at Columbia University in the City of New York. His most recent book is Gang Leader for a Day (Penguin Press). Gang Leader received a Best Book award from The Economist, and is currently being translated into Chinese, Korean, Japanese, German, Italian, Polish, French and Portuguese. His previous work, Off the Books: The Underground Economy of the Urban Poor (Harvard University Press, 2006) about illegal economies in Chicago, received a Best Book Award from Slate.com (2006) as well as the C. Wright Mills Award (2007). His first book, American Project: The Rise and Fall of a Modern Ghetto (2000) explored life in Chicago public housing. Venkatesh’ editorial writings have appeared in The New York Times, the Chicago Tribune, and the Washington Post. He writes for Slate.com, and his stories have appeared in This American Life, WIRED, and on National Public Radio. His next book, under contract with Penguin Press, will focus on the role of black market economies—from sex work and drug trafficking to day care and entertainment—in the revitalization of New York since 1999. Venkatesh is completing an ethnographic study of policing in the Department of Justice, where he served as a Senior Research Advisor from 2010-2011. Venkatesh’s first documentary film, Dislocation, followed families as they relocated from condemned public housing developments. The documentary aired on PBS in 2005. He directed and produced a three-part award winning documentary on the history of public housing for public radio. And, he recently completed At the Top of My Voice, a documentary film on a scholar and artist who return to the ex-Soviet republic of Georgia to promote democracy and safeguard human rights. Venkatesh received his Ph.D. in Sociology from the University of Chicago. He was a Junior Fellow at the Society of Fellows, Harvard University from 1996-1999, and an NSF CAREER award recipient in 2000. He holds a visiting appointment in Columbia University’s Law School and he is a voting member of the Institute for Research in African-American Studies.
用户评论
"A drug economy, he told me, was ‘useful for the community,’since it redistributed the drug addicts’ money back into the community via the gang’s philanthropy."一笑。在《火线》里就感觉贩毒也只是(百无聊赖的)生活方式之一罢了。
读完最大的感触是在黑帮介入管理的社区的系统里,每个人的各司其职与见缝插针显得如此精巧。作者的感情太充沛了,废话很多。英文很简单,权当练阅读。
昨晚终于把最后两章翻完了。这是一个最初拿着Likert量表问卷去问黑老大你幸福吗的社会学博士生,最终走上田野调查不归路的故事。喜闻乐见。
可惜的是兄台是个Sociology的学生 换成我大Anthro的必须比这还深刻精彩
身為香港人這些故事應該耳熟能詳
英文版又读了一遍,从原来的文本中其实更能感受到当一整套与我们熟知的道德规则呈现在面前时的震撼。我们时常混淆知识与经验的范畴。知识无法代替经验,而仅凭经验也无法成为知识。当作者将社区中的道德准则,与共识中的道德准则之间的冲突展现在读者面前,或是经验材料中时,是否将这一问题悬置影响着研究的进行。当我们面对结构性的不义和不公正时,这种无力感简直一模一样。我能够从这本书里得到更多的体会,而不仅仅是贫困、地下经济和道德标准的冲突。正如中国部分人正在经历的生活一样,他们遭遇着结构性的不公,但“聪明的人”会选择耸耸肩、接受命运,逆来顺受地活下去,并进一步地在本来不利于自身地社会结构中,通过一些取巧,来为自己牟利。
跟在芝加哥黑帮大佬屁股后面做研究的流水账。作者真的naive,大家好像在babysitting「你不能去这里不能去那里不然我没法保护你!」不过看到最后一章J.T.「He's with me」那几句话还是有被感动:(
有点散乱,更像是流水账记录,但是仍然是精彩的。(spy)fly on the wall的观察记录 挺有意思的 最开始是freakanomics里面讲到他
我是第一次读这种探访黑帮背后的“田野笔记”,若不把它视为严谨的学术研究,故事本身还是精彩的。我也可以理解goodreads上的一些差评,作者确实“傻白甜”的过分了(哪有不打人的黑帮大佬),难怪大家会对他的专业性提出质疑。
好吧,新鲜感过后,感觉在读写的一般的小说了。不知道这样做qualitative research是否valid
收藏