America for Americans - Erika Lee

America for Americans

Erika Lee

出版社

Basic Books

出版时间

2019-11-26

ISBN

9781541672604

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

An award-winning historian reframes our continuing debate over immigration with a compelling history of xenophobia in the United States and its devastating impact

The United States is known as a nation of immigrants. But it is also a nation of xenophobia. In America for Americans, Erika Lee shows that an irrational fear, hatred, and hostility toward immigrants has been a defining feature of our nation from the colonial era to the Trump era. Benjamin Franklin ridiculed Germans for their "strange and foreign ways." Americans' anxiety over Irish Catholics turned xenophobia into a national political movement. Chinese immigrants were excluded, Japanese incarcerated, and Mexicans deported. Today, Americans fear Muslims, Latinos, and the so-called browning of America.

Forcing us to confront this history, America for Americans explains how xenophobia works, why it has endured, and how it threatens America. It is a necessary corrective and spur to action for any concerned citizen.

Erika Lee is a Regents Professor, the Rudolph J. Vecoli Chair in Immigration History, and director of the Immigration History Research Center at the University of Minnesota. The author of The Making of Asian America and other award-winning books, Lee lives in Minneapolis, MN.

用户评论
一段时期内读到的最gratifying的书
对川普时代的response,关于美国排外主义的作品。在实践中写成了对各个不同少数移民族裔在不同历史时期遭遇的编年史,从爱尔兰裔、东欧裔到华人、菲律宾人一个不落。Inclusion与Exclusion本是一体两面,政治构建需要前者,但遗憾的是可能更需要后者。
“Why do we need to learn history?" 我们为什么需要了解历史?“Because history tells us that the present is not inevitable." 因为历史让我们知道,当下并不是必然的。看了这本书,听了Dr. Lee的讲座,写了一长篇文章,发在我公众号“琥珀大王”了,就不搬运过来啦!
Broward County Library
intro和conclusion章节写得很精准和激昂,中间章节却成了为了证明论点而堆砌的流水账。作为前历史学生还是批判一下,这样宏大而现实意义丰富的题材实在容易流于表面。然而只为了作者的一个核心观点也要多加一颗星:a nation of immigrants和a nation of xenophobia,这两个概念,在美国历史上一直是共存的,只不过是一枚硬币的两面罢了。就如同,无数移民群体前一秒还向往美国的大门,跨进来以后下一秒就想把门给别人关上,是一个道理。从这个角度来说,不管是持哪方观点,把某个移民群体划分为“善”与“恶”,乃至把“欢迎移民”和“不欢迎移民”的态度也划分为“善”与“恶”的道德讨论,本身就是无稽之谈。换句话说,整个的美国移民史也许只是无数个历史现实下人们的本能反应罢了。
收藏