The Great Leveler - Walter Scheidel

The Great Leveler

Walter Scheidel

出版时间

2017-01-24

ISBN

9780691165028

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
Are mass violence and catastrophes the only forces that can seriously decrease economic inequality? To judge by thousands of years of history, the answer is yes. Tracing the global history of inequality from the Stone Age to today, Walter Scheidel shows that inequality never dies peacefully. Periods of increased equality are usually born of carnage and disaster and are generally short-lived, disappearing with the return of peace and stability. The Great Leveler is the first book to chart the crucial role of violent shocks in reducing inequality over the full sweep of human history around the world. Ever since humans began to farm, herd livestock, and pass on their assets to future generations, economic inequality has been a defining feature of civilization. Over thousands of years, only violent events have significantly lessened inequality. The "Four Horsemen" of leveling—mass-mobilization warfare, transformative revolutions, state collapse, and catastrophic plagues—have repeatedly destroyed the fortunes of the rich. Scheidel identifies and examines these processes, from the crises of the earliest civilizations to the cataclysmic world wars and communist revolutions of the twentieth century. Today, the violence that reduced inequality in the past seems to have diminished, and that is a good thing. But it casts serious doubt on the prospects for a more equal future. An essential contribution to the debate about inequality, The Great Leveler provides important new insights about why inequality is so persistent—and why it is unlikely to decline anytime soon.
AI导读
核心看点
  • 揭示暴力冲击是缩小贫富差距的关键
  • 提出战争、革命、崩溃、瘟疫四骑士
  • 论证社会稳定往往加剧经济不平等
适合谁读
  • 对全球历史与社会不平等感兴趣的读者
  • 关注政治经济学与社会学研究的学者
  • 希望理解贫富分化历史根源的普通大众
读前提醒
  • 需具备一定历史与经济学基础知识
  • 观点激进,需辩证看待其宿命论色彩
  • 中文版翻译质量参差不齐,建议慎选
读者共识
  • 史料详实,全球史视野宏大且震撼
  • 逻辑严密但理论挖掘深度略显不足
  • 对和平解决不平等持极度悲观态度

本导读基于书籍简介、目录、原文摘录、短评和书评生成,不等同于全文精读。

精彩摘录
  • "更为安全的产权和国家承诺加强了对世袭私人财富的保护。千年来,文明社会并没有让自己适应和平的平等化进程。对于广泛的社会范围和不同的发展水平,稳定都会助长经济不平等。暴力性冲击对破坏既定秩序,压缩收入和财富的分布,缩小贫富差距都是至关重要的。在整个有记载的历史进程中,最有力的矫正作用总是由最有力的冲击引起的。4种不同类型的暴力冲击缓和了不平等:大规模动员战争、变革性的革命、国家衰败和致命传染病。我将这些称为矫正力量的四骑士。等到尘埃落定的时候,富人和穷人之间的差距缩小了,有时甚至急剧缩小了。"
  • "乞讨、行骗和盗窃有助于获得更为平等的资源分配。对独裁主义行为及其扩张的制裁方式包括谣言、批评、奚落、违抗、放逐,甚至包含谋杀在内的身体暴力。"
  • "in the early fourteenth century, the average Cairene might consume a modest 1,154 calories per day, including 45.6 grams of protein and 20 grams of fat, but by the mid-fifteenth century was able to dispose of 1,930 calories, including 82 grams of protein and 45 grams of fat."
  • "new ways to grow. For thousands of years, civilization did not lend itselfBniahionterss to peaceful equalization Across a wide range of societiesand different levels of development, stability favoredeconomic inequality. This was as true of Pharaonic Egyptas it was of Victorian England, as true of th"
作者简介
Walter Scheidel is the Dickason Professor in the Humanities, professor of classics and history, and a Kennedy-Grossman Fellow in Human Biology at Stanford University. The author or editor of sixteen previous books, he has published widely on premodern social and economic history, demography, and comparative history. He lives in Palo Alto, California.
用户评论
促使社会平等的四股力量:战争、革命、灭国、瘟疫。导致社会不平等加剧的力量:社会稳定。
有趣的观点
打包的全球史。写了足足500页关于「不平等如何不可避免」,也算是这个题材下的重磅作品。但这种高度抽象概括的作品如何与地方性的人或者团体的具体历史体验联系起来是我现在的疑问。书里引了兰克的「如实直说」,但史学家都明白个中的局限吧?题外话,这书的中文版是怎么出的……
只有四类毁灭性灾难才能打破不平等,拉近阶级差距: 1、大规模的瘟疫或流行病,如中世纪的黑死病; 2、国家解体:如唐朝与罗马帝国的灭亡; 3、大革命,如彻底推翻旧制度的俄国与中国革命; 4、国际性战争:如大战期间通过大幅提高利息税与财产税,以及恶性通胀强制国民为战争牺牲,强行抹平贫富差距。
8.5/10. 不平等的常态是上升,只有战争、革命、社会崩溃和瘟疫才能让它降低,而且机制都是靠大批死人:战争必须大动员,未来高科技战争恐怕没用;革命暴力到法国大革命的程度也就是勉强降低一点,想大规模降低不平等得靠列斯毛波尔布特杀人;瘟疫也要黑死病那个级别的,阿冠这种不够看。没证据表明不平等本身会导致这些平等化机制降临。不过写当代政经展望未来的部分一般,也流于肤浅的俗套。
博闻强记的作者 典范的全球史写作 但是malign和benign措施的区别真的有那么大吗?(degree or deed?)
收藏