The Foucault Reader

Michel Foucault, Paul Rabinow (editor)

出版时间

1984-11-12

ISBN

9780394713403

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
Michel Foucault was one of the most influential thinkers in the contemporary world, someone whose work has affected the teaching of half a dozen disciplines ranging from literary criticism to the history of criminology. But of his many books, not one offers a satisfactory introduction to the entire complex body of his work. The Foucault Reader was commissioned precisely to serve that purpose. The Reader contains selections from each area of Foucault's work as well as a wealth of previously unpublished writings, including important material written especially for this volume, the preface to the long-awaited second volume of The History of Sexuality, and interviews with Foucault himself, in the course of which he discussed his philosophy at first hand and with unprecedented candor. This philosophy comprises an astonishing intellectual enterprise: a minute and ongoing investigation of the nature of power in society. Foucault's analyses of this power as it manifests itself in society, schools, hospitals, factories, homes, families, and other forms of organized society are brought together in The Foucault Reader to create an overview of this theme and of the broad social and political vision that underlies it.
AI导读
编辑书评
  • 本书的真正价值不在于提供答案,而在于展示一种提问的方式。拉比诺的编辑工作极为出色,他并未试图简化福柯的复杂性,而是通过精心编排,让读者看到思想如何在不同领域间流动与变形。与同类导读相比,它的独特之处在于保留了原文的肌理与张力,避免了二手解读常见的扁平化倾向。对于愿意承受认知摩擦的读者,这是一次重塑思维结构的训练;但对于寻求速成知识的读者,这可能是一场灾难。值得读,但必须带着敬畏与耐心。
  • 局限在于其仍受限于选篇视角,无法完全替代原著的深度挖掘。某些关键概念的演变过程在短文中可能被压缩,导致初学者误以为福柯的思想是静态的体系。然而,作为一本“元书”,它成功地确立了福柯在当代思想史上的坐标。它不仅是文献汇编,更是一部关于“如何阅读福柯”的教学手册。建议在完成初步通读后,针对感兴趣的章节回溯原著,如此方能真正领会那种在历史废墟中重建主体性的震撼力量。
核心看点
  • 本书由保罗·拉比诺编选,旨在填补福柯缺乏系统性入门读物的空白。它并非简单摘录,而是精心构建了从知识考古学到权力谱系学的完整思想地图,收录了《什么是启蒙》、尼采谱系学论述及大量未公开访谈。通过呈现福柯对主体性、话语形成及规训机制的剖析,读者能直观把握其如何解构传统历史观与哲学本体论,理解“人”作为近期发明的脆弱性及其在权力网络中的位置。
  • 核心看点在于福柯独特的方法论转换:从寻找事物的本质起源转向追踪力量的偶然涌现与离散过程。书中精选文本展示了“谱系学”如何作为一种反目的论的历史工具,揭示真理、知识与制度背后的权力斗争而非理性进步。特别是关于“作者功能”与“话语存在模式”的论述,挑战了将文本视为作者意图载体的传统观念,转而关注话语如何在社会中被流通、估值和归属,为文化研究提供了极具操作性的分析框架。
  • 本书的另一大价值是收录了福柯亲自参与的政治实践反思与伦理思考,尤其是关于性与权力的讨论。不同于早期著作侧重宏观结构,后期选文聚焦于个体如何通过自我技术构建主体性。拉比诺的编者序言与福柯的访谈相互印证,展现了思想家在面对具体政治议题时的犹豫、修正与坚持。这种第一人称的坦诚叙述,让抽象的理论落地为可感知的智识挣扎,帮助读者理解福柯思想中伦理维度与政治维度的内在张力。
读者共识
  • 多数读者认为本书是进入福柯思想世界的最佳入门路径,尽管承认其难度极高。评论普遍指出,相比直接啃读大部头专著,通过Reader精选的短文能更清晰地捕捉到福柯的核心关切,如权力、知识、身体与规训。许多资深读者表示,重读此书常有新发现,因为它浓缩了福柯最具代表性的洞见,是“管中窥豹”的理想载体。
  • 争议主要集中在文本的可读性与完整性上。一部分读者抱怨翻译生硬、概念晦涩,甚至戏称其为“装逼指南”,认为若无深厚哲学功底难以消化。另一部分则赞赏其选材的经典性,认为这确实是福柯自己认可的代表作集合。然而,也有遗憾之声指出,书中未收录某些著名辩论(如与乔姆斯基的对谈),使得对福柯公共知识分子形象的展现略显不足。
  • 读者高度认可本书在学术写作范式上的示范意义。多位评论提到,福柯的文章结构严谨、论证有力,是撰写学术论文的典范。特别是关于“谱系学”方法的阐述,被认为具有极强的方法论启示,不仅适用于历史研究,也可迁移至文学、艺术等领域。总体而言,虽然阅读体验痛苦,但读者普遍认为这种智力挑战是值得的,收获远超预期。
精彩摘录
  • "Weber, although often cast as a conservative, offers a devastating account of modern capitalism which certainly does not suggest that he wished to preserve it whole. Foucault has been cast as a conservative by some, in the sense that he has consistently opposed much of modern French Marxism, "existi"
  • "And this is what I would call genealogy, that is, a form of history which can account for the constitution of knowledges, discourses, domains of objects, etc., without having to make reference to a subject which is either transcendental in relation to the field of events or runs in its empty samenes"
  • "Why does Nietzsche challenge the pursuit of origin (Ursprung), at least on those occasions when he is truly a genealogist? First, because it is an attempt to capture the exact essence of things, their purest possibilities, and their carefully protected identities; because this search assumes the exi"
  • "The analysis of descent permits the dissociation of the self, its recognition and displacement as an empty synthesis, in liberating a profusion of lost events. On the contrary, to follow the complex course of descent is to maintain passing events in their proper dispersion; it is to identify the acc"
  • "Emergence is thus the entry of forces; it is their eruption, the leap from the wings to center stage, each in its youthful strength...As descent qualifies the strength or weakness of an instinct and its inscription on a body, emergence designates a place of confrontation, but not as a closed field o"
  • "Chance is not simply the drawing of lots, but raising the stakes in every attempt to master chance through the will to power, and giving rise to the risk of an even greater chance. The world we know is not this ultimately simple configuration where events are reduced to accentuate their essential tr"
  • "The historical sense gives rise to three uses that oppose and correspond to the three Platonic modalities of history. The first is parodic, directed against reality, and opposes them of history as reminiscence or recognition; the second is dissociative, directed against identity, and opposes history"
  • "Perhaps it is time to study discourses not only in terms of their expressive value or formal transformation, but according to their modes of existence. The modes of circulation, valorization, attribution, and appropriation of discourses vary with each culture and are modified within each."
用户评论
不少来自规训与惩罚、性史。读了其中的采访,基本和讲稿差别不大。非常有味道
Foucault revisited
Foucault is as difficult to read as all those contemporary French scholars...But he did fashion a frame-transition in modern thoughts.
未完,目前对其中的一些议题不感兴趣
Rabinow wonderfully recapitulates the major thrusts throughout Foucault's multiple works, of astonishingly equally elegant language.
What is Enlightenment, Right of death and power over life, we other Victorians
不适合作为读福柯的第一本书。编者从福柯的主要著作中选取部分章节 (有时候会打乱章节顺序),又进一步删减原文内容。缺失的原境给阅读带来很大障碍,得不断回去找原著才能达到基本的理解。福柯在性史第一卷讲到他所说的power是什么,居然没有把这部分选进来,而对power的理解和把握对于第一次阅读福柯的读者太重要了,因为福柯说的power如果理解成权力就错了,那是结果,福柯说的power是动态的、细微的、千丝万缕的关系。最后面的几个访谈值得一看,福柯讲他的思考脉络。three domains of genealogy: truth axis, power axis, ethical axis.
I tried, but this is a pain to read... 有些文章節選得失去了上下文都不知所云了。
What is enlightenment?
He is no longer the rhapsodist of the eternal, but the strategist of life and death. (P77). 老老实实读了Nietzsche, Genealogy, History这一节。
全部深度解读 →主题书单高分榜最近更新