Depositions - Amy Knight Powell

Depositions

Amy Knight Powell

出版社

Zone Books

出版时间

2012-03-09

ISBN

9781935408208

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
From late medieval reenactments of the Deposition from the Cross to Sol Lewitt's Buried Cube, Depositions is about taking down images and about images that anticipate being taken down. Foretelling their own depositions, as well as their re-elevations in contexts far from those in which they were made, the images studied in this book reveal themselves to be untimely--no truer to their first appearance than to their later reappearances. In Depositions, Amy Powell makes the case that late medieval paintings and ritual reenactments of the Deposition from the Cross not only picture the deposition of Christ (the Imago Dei) but also allegorize the deposition of the image as such and, in so doing, prefigure the lowering of "dead images" during the Protestant Reformation. Late medieval pre-figurations of Reformation iconoclasm anticipate, in turn, the repeated "deaths" of art since the advent of photography: that is the premise of the vignettes devoted to twentieth-century works of art that conclude each chapter of this book. In these vignettes, images that once stood in late medieval churches now find themselves among works of art from the more recent past with which they share certain formal characteristics. These surreal encounters compel us to reckon with affinities between images from different times and places. Turning pseudomorphosis--formal resemblance where there is no similarity of artistic intent -- on its head, Powell explores what happens to our understanding of historically and conceptually distant works of art when they look alike.
用户评论
出版十年之后终于比较迅速地读了一下这本当年一夜成名的作品,虽然被当时学界推举为某种学界先锋,其实这本书实在是incredibly well-written and accessible。Powell的勇气在于逆她所谓neo-vitalism的潮流,强调图像始终是在无机与生命力之间辩证摆荡的存在。甚至在她写完此书的十年之内,“能动性”、“拟人论”依然在学界对物质、图像等等的讨论中盛行。或许是因为这样的勇气,Bynum才在第一时间称赞这本书。此外,中世纪晚期的宗教艺术和社群实在是极其复杂而异质的领域,如果Powell认为木材是死的,那么Bryda的新书似乎恰恰想说木材充满了精神性,或许恰恰是在这些争端中,宗教改革才会应运而生。
在我有限的艺术史著作阅读经验里,这本可以说相当不同寻常。它的重点本是,用“image that invites its own destrction”将宗教改革前后中艺术作品里的Deposition和图像破坏联系在一起,然而在每个章节的最后作者都会将章节的内容和某个当代艺术作品联系起来也绝非常规艺术史写作手法,作者旁征博引的能力也令人佩服。不管怎么样,是很重要同时也不那么容易的著作,除了概念复杂之外,涉及到大量宗教文化史以及宗教仪式的内容也会让人放慢阅读速度,不过好在作者的语言相对来说比较直接好懂。
收藏