The New Jim Crow

Michelle Alexander

出版时间

2012-01-16

ISBN

9781595586438

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

The New Jim Crow was initially published with a modest first printing and reasonable expectations for a hard-hitting book on a tough topic. Now, ten-plus printings later, the long-awaited paperback version of the book Lani Guinier calls "brave and bold," and Pulitzer Prize–winner David Levering Lewis calls "stunning," will at last be available.

In the era of colorblindness, it is no longer socially permissible to use race, explicitly, as a justification for discrimination, exclusion, and social contempt. Yet, as legal star Michelle Alexander reveals, today it is perfectly legal to discriminate against convicted criminals in nearly all the ways that it was once legal to discriminate against African Americans. Once you're labeled a felon, the old forms of discrimination—employment discrimination, housing discrimination, denial of the right to vote, denial of educational opportunity, denial of food stamps and other public benefits, and exclusion from jury service—are suddenly legal.

Featured on The Tavis Smiley Show, Bill Moyers Journal, Democracy Now, and C-Span's Washington Journal, The New Jim Crow has become an overnight phenomenon, sparking a much-needed conversation—including a recent mention by Cornel West on Real Time with Bill Maher&mdas;about ways in which our system of mass incarceration has come to resemble systems of racial control from a different era.

A longtime civil rights advocate and litigator, Michelle Alexander won a 2005 Soros Justice Fellowship and now holds a joint appointment at the Moritz College of Law and the Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity at Ohio State University. Alexander served for several years as the director of the Racial Justice Project at the ACLU of Northern California, which spea...

(展开全部)

AI导读
核心看点
  • 本书深刻揭露美国在所谓‘色盲’时代下,通过大规模监禁构建的新型种族种姓制度。作者指出,虽然公开基于种族的歧视已不再合法,但针对罪犯的歧视性政策实际上合法化了对非裔美国人的系统性排斥,包括剥夺投票权、就业歧视及住房限制,形成现代版的吉姆·克劳法。
  • 书中详细剖析‘战争毒品’运动如何成为大规模监禁的推手。作者论证该运动并非旨在解决毒品问题,而是通过严苛的法律、强制最低刑期及资产没收政策,将非裔社区边缘化。这种执法策略导致监狱人口激增,且主要针对有色人种,无论其实际涉毒程度如何,均受到不成比例的打击。
  • 作者批判当前司法体系将犯罪者标签化为‘二等公民’,剥夺其尊严与社会权利。书中强调,这种制度性压迫不仅摧毁个人生活,更撕裂社区纽带,使出狱者难以回归社会,从而陷入再犯罪的恶性循环。作者呼吁公众认清这一隐蔽的种族控制机制,并推动根本性的司法与社会改革,以终结这种不公正的种姓体系。
适合谁读
  • 对美国刑事司法体系、种族关系及社会正义议题感兴趣的读者。本书适合希望深入了解美国系统性种族主义运作机制,特别是大规模监禁如何作为社会控制工具的历史与现状的读者。对于关注法律伦理、人权保护及社会不平等问题的人士,本书提供了极具冲击力的视角与详实的论证,有助于提升批判性思维。
  • 社会学、法学、政治学及相关专业的学生与研究者。本书为理解美国当代社会结构、种族分层及司法政策提供了重要的理论框架与案例支持。书中关于‘色盲’意识形态的批判、对执法偏差的分析以及对制度性歧视的揭露,可作为学术研究与课堂讨论的重要素材,帮助读者从宏观层面审视社会不公的根源。
  • 关注全球人权状况、反种族歧视运动及社会改革动向的公众。无论身处何种文化背景,读者均可从中反思自身社会中是否存在类似的系统性压迫机制。本书适合那些希望超越表面现象,深入探究结构性暴力、司法不公及其对弱势群体深远影响的读者,激发对正义、平等及社会责任的深刻思考与行动意愿。
读前提醒
  • 阅读时需保持批判性思维,注意区分作者观点与客观事实。部分读者指出书中存在数据引用争议、逻辑跳跃及过度简化复杂社会问题的情况。建议结合其他学术研究、统计数据及不同立场的评论进行交叉验证,以全面理解美国司法体系的复杂性,避免陷入单一叙事,确保对议题有平衡、客观的认识。
  • 本书涉及大量美国历史背景,如奴隶制、吉姆·克劳法、民权运动及‘战争毒品’政策。若缺乏相关知识储备,可能影响对作者论证逻辑的理解。建议读者在阅读前或阅读过程中,主动补充相关历史与法律背景资料,以便准确把握作者对历史延续性与制度变迁的批判,深入体会书中揭示的结构性压迫的严重性。
  • 书中内容涉及大量系统性不公与暴力执法案例,情感基调沉重,可能引发读者的愤怒、焦虑或无力感。建议读者合理安排阅读节奏,避免长时间沉浸于负面情绪中。同时,可将阅读视为一种认知觉醒的过程,关注书中提出的改革方向与社会行动可能性,将负面情绪转化为对正义的追求与对现实问题的理性探讨,而非单纯的情绪宣泄。
读者共识
  • 读者普遍认可本书在揭示美国大规模监禁背后的种族主义本质方面具有开创性与震撼力。尽管部分观点存在争议,但书中对司法系统如何系统性压迫非裔社区、剥夺其公民权利的描述触目惊心,引发广泛共鸣。许多读者认为本书是理解当代美国种族问题与司法不公的关键读物,其揭露的‘新型吉姆·克劳’现象令人警醒,具有极高的社会警示价值。
  • 部分读者批评书中缺乏严谨的数据支持,逻辑论证存在漏洞,甚至被指为‘政治正确’的产物。有评论指出作者混淆了激进执法与大规模监禁的概念,且未充分考量阶层差异对犯罪率的影响。然而,即便持保留态度的读者也承认,书中对制度性歧视的批判具有启发性,促使人们反思现有司法体系的缺陷,但其结论的绝对性与部分论证的薄弱性限制了其学术说服力。
  • 读者一致认为本书具有强烈的煽动性与情感冲击力,作者文笔流畅,善于激发读者的道德义愤。尽管缺乏具体的解决方案,但书中对现状的揭露足以推动公众意识觉醒。许多读者表示,阅读后对美国司法体系的信任度大幅下降,并更加关注种族正义与社会改革议题。本书被视为理解美国社会深层矛盾的重要窗口,但其激进立场也导致部分读者对其客观性产生质疑,建议谨慎对待其极端结论。

本导读基于书籍简介、目录、原文摘录、短评和书评生成,不等同于全文精读。

精彩摘录
  • "The fact that some African Americans have experienced great success in recent years does not mean that something akin to a racial caste system no longer exists. No caste system in the United States has ever governed all black people; there have always been "free blacks" and black success stories, ev"
  • "Wittingly or unwittingly, they found themselves complicit in the emergence of a penal system unprecedented in world history. Black support for harsh responses to urban crime -- support born of desperation and legitimate concern over the unraveling of basic security in inner-city communities -- helpe"
  • "In the city of Minneapolis, Minnesota, for example, its SWAT team was deployed on no-knock warrant thirty-five times in 1986, but in 1996 that same team was deployed for drug raids more than seven hundred times."
  • "Arguably the most significant reform is the creation of an "innocent owner" defense. Prior to the Reform Act, the Supreme Court had ruled that the guilt or innocence of the property's owner was irrelevant to the property's guilt--a ruling based on the archaic legal fiction that a piece of property c"
  • "Criminals, it turns out, are the one social group in America we have permission to hate. In "colorblind" America, criminals are the new whipping boys. They are entitled to no respect and little moral concern. Like the "coloreds" in the years following emancipation, criminals today are deemed a chara"
  • "The genius of the current caste system, and what most distinguishes it from its predecessors, is that it appears voluntary. People choose to commit crimes, and that's why they are locked up or locked out, we are told. This feature makes the politics of responsibility particularly tempting, as it app"
  • "The notion that a vast gulf exists between "criminals" and those of us who have never served time in prison is a fiction created by the racial ideology that birthed mass incarceration, namely that there is something fundamentally wrong and morally inferior about "them." The reality, though, is that "
  • "Our racially biased system of mass incarceration exploits the fact that all people break the law and make mistakes at various points in their lives and with varying degrees of justification. Screwing up--failing to live by one's highest ideals and values--is part of what makes us human."
作者简介
A longtime civil rights advocate and litigator, Michelle Alexander won a 2005 Soros Justice Fellowship and now holds a joint appointment at the Moritz College of Law and the Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity at Ohio State University. Alexander served for several years as the director of the Racial Justice Project at the ACLU of Northern California, which spearheaded the national campaign against racial profiling. At the beginning of her career she served as a law clerk on the United States Supreme Court for Justice Harry Blackmun. She lives outside Columbus, Ohio.
目录
1. The Rebirth of Caste
2. The Lockdown
3. The Color of Justice
4. The Cruel Hand
5. The New Jim Crow

显示全部
用户评论
拖好久才读这本可能是近年关于美国刑事司法系统最著名的作品(标题比内容更加出圈),文采非常好,遣词用句具有煽动性。虽然有些观点说服力不足,而另一些现在看来有点陈词滥调,但是作者做的两方面的延伸是非常出彩的:一是强调了在执法过程中civil forfeiture的巨大破坏性和波及力,二是说明mass incarceration和affirmative action "are linked more than we realize"。作者认为AA把所有人的正义转化成了部分人的好处,是"racial justice purchased on the cheap",而且对正义的追求应该让所有族群都受益,而不是把它转化为族群之间相互倾轧的零和游戏,这样才能团结所有可能盟友撬动深刻改变,观点理想但丰满。
姑且打三星,需要继续看下去再给评论/观点是不错,但是根本不存在例子和数据,怪不得这本书会成为acab疯子的圣经
反正我是跳着看的
绝对是重要的作品,虽然觉得Alexander偶尔还是混淆了aggressive policing和mass incarceration,并且从某种程度上绕开了阶层差异,但是对于racial undercaste的二等公民描述还是触目惊心,尤其是和其他相关研究(e.g. school to prison pipeline)联系起来的话真是很难对现状感到乐观。
America fucking sucks. You let humanity run free and you get its violent ends. Why is that so hard to acknowledge for so many?
偏通俗类,搞这个的一半撇嘴一半羡慕((。analogy铿锵有力但常被诟病不够准确,which is true…
Comprehensive and helpful guide to an important social issue
An easy, gripping read, despite the subject matter. The most accessible, and yet comprehensive introduction I’ve read of the mass incarceration system in the us. I’m not new to the topic, but still gained new and deeper understanding of the issue. Would recommend to anyone who is interested in the justice system and r8cism in the us.
推荐给所有对mass incarceration感兴趣的人,入门友好书籍
收藏