The Rise of the Meritocracy - Michael Young

The Rise of the Meritocracy

Michael Young

出版时间

1993-12-31

ISBN

9781560007043

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Michael Young has christened the oligarchy of the future “Meritocracy.” Indeed, the word is now part of the English language. It would appear that the formula: IQ+Effort=Merit may well constitute the basic belief of the ruling class in the twenty-first century. Projecting himself into the year 2034, the author of this sociological satire shows how present decisions and practices may remold our society.

It is widespread knowledge that it is insufficient to be somebody's nephew to obtain a responsible post in business, government, teaching, or science. Experts in education and selection apply scientific principles to sift out the leaders of tomorrow. You need intelligence rating, qualification, experience, application, and a certain caliber to achieve status. In a word, one must show merit to advance in the new society of tomorrow.

In a new opening essay, Young reflects on the reception of his work, and its production, in a candid and lively way. Many of the critical ambiguities surrounding its original publication are now clarified and resolved. What we have is what the Guardian of London called “A brilliant essay.” and what Time and Tide described as “a fountain gush of new ideas. Its wit and style make it compulsively enjoyable reading from cover to cover.”

Michael F.D. Young studied at the universities of Cambridge and Essex and the former Regent Polytechnic. He is Senior Lecturer in Sociology of Education at the University of London Institute of Education, and was previously Head of Science at the London Nautical School

用户评论
改一下补标,杨虽然对历史性和知识还有权利的理解很差劲,但是比当时的自由主义者强不少了
隔靴搔痒
可能因为语言能力的关系,第一遍读得很粗,大概囫囵吞枣都没达到,有些地方基本就是在读单词,很多逻辑关系也没有厘清。最关键的是,因为是上世纪五十年代对2033年的想象,即便我们今天还没有到本世纪的三十年代,但对作者在描述上世纪六十年代之后到2020年的事情依然会时不时地出离,会把那些当成真的历史,而非作者自身的想象。令人击节的是,作者很多的预测在今天,还没有到2033年便成为了真实。 不知道这是一种不幸还是庆幸,也不知道有没有resolution,似乎在书里没有读到。毕竟作者只是想提个醒,但既然提醒没有起到作用,那今天的我们该如何去改变呢?这大概就是我们今天面对的困境吧。
1958年出版的虚构的未来历史视角的书。作者的虚构作者的思路是,民主制只是世袭制度到meritocracy的过渡。在世袭制度时期,智力是差不多一样比例分布在不同阶层的,民主制让低阶层的人里聪明人士上升到高阶层了,等到这个筛选都完成并稳定后,民主制的历史使命也就完成了。书里大篇幅描述教育、政府用人和企业用人,我对历史和英国政治了解不足以看懂那些。作者设想的未来历史里,对meritocracy的反抗来自女权主义运动,我想不清楚他这样设计说明了什么:)很多未来历史的‘预测’和现实有点出入,有些地方却很奇怪地和现在相符。我最喜欢的地方是借反对方之口说出了根本的解决方案,和我之前看tyranny of merit时的想法是差不多的,就是我们需要价值观diveristy。另外一定要看最后一个脚注:)
一本纯粹虚构的书,从未来「回看」过去一百年的英国。作者说Intelligence and effort together make up merit。但是这是一个所有人一辈子时时刻刻都在打拼的世界,究竟是异托邦还是唱赞歌?有些想法还是满有意思的。
整本书建立在一个大型的乌托邦/思想实验社会之上,并looking backward/分析来时的路。merit真是一个很讽刺的评价标准,某种意义上建立了平等的社会,又抛弃了平等的社会。
收藏