书籍介绍
bell hooks 在这本书里抛出一个尖锐的问题：当女性主义运动以“姐妹情谊”相称时，为何有色人种女性始终被排除在外？她揭示了一个令人不适的真相——白人主流女权往往把“解放”等同于“能像男人一样行事”，结果只是让少数女性得以充当男人的替身，而非真正颠覆结构。更痛的是，黑人女性被迫在男性主导的民权运动与白人主导的女权运动之间左右为难，两头都被排斥。这本书的价值，不在于提供一套完美的行动纲领，而在于逼读者承认：种族、阶级、性别层层相扣，斩断其中任何一环，其他都不会真正松动。它适合那些不满足于口号式团结、愿意直面运动内部裂痕的人。
作者简介
One of the leading public intellectuals of her generation, bell hooks has authored over 20 books, including several classics in African-American and Women's Studies. Known mainly as a feminist thinker, hooks addresses a broad range of issues related to gender, race, teaching, and media, always advancing the understanding that these topics must be conceived of as interconnected, not isolated strands.
AI导读
核心看点
- 本书深入剖析种族主义、阶级压迫与性别歧视的交织关系，揭示白人主导的女权运动如何系统性排斥黑人女性，批判其忽视贫困与非白人女性生存困境的局限性。
- 作者追溯奴隶制以来黑人女性在美国社会中的边缘化历史，揭露父权制与资本主义合谋下，黑人女性遭受的双重甚至多重压迫，强调打破权力结构才是实现真正平等的唯一途径。
- 书中严厉批评女权运动内部存在的种族偏见与阶级盲视，指出单纯采用女权修辞无法消除性别歧视，呼吁建立包容不同种族、阶级背景的团结，反对任何形式的压迫性权力结构。
读者共识
- 读者普遍认为本书是理解黑人女性主义及交叉性压迫的入门必读经典，其揭示的系统性不公令人震撼且痛彻心扉，虽部分观点因年代久远需结合当下语境反思，但其批判精神至今仍有强烈现实意义。
- 许多读者指出书中揭露的女权运动内部种族与阶级排斥问题具有普世警示意义，提醒人们警惕任何形式的特权盲视，强调真正的解放必须建立在消除所有压迫性权力结构的基础上，而非部分群体的特权获取。
- 尽管部分读者认为书中历史叙述较多且理论深度有限，或行文存在重复啰嗦之处，但大家一致认可其打破白人男性主导叙事、揭示被遮蔽历史真相的巨大价值，认为其带来的思想冲击远超阅读不适。
精彩摘录
- "All too frequently in the women’s movement it was assumed one could be free of sexist thinking by simply adopting the appropriate feminist rhetoric; it was further assumed that identifying oneself as oppressed freed one from being an oppressor. To a very grave extent such thinking prevented.white fe"
- "contemporary black women felt they were asked to choose between a black movement that primarily served the interests of black male patriarchs and a women’s movement which primarily served the interests of racist white women."
- "The great majority of black women allied themselves with the black patriarchy they believed would protect their interests. A few black women chose to ally themselves with the feminist movement. ... Other women found themselves in limbo, not wanting to ally themselves..with sexist women."
用户评论
Black women dealt with “A liberation movement that’s inherently sexist, and a feminism movement that’s inherently racist”
Ain’t I a Woman! 白男主导的文学世界如此狭隘，不被看见的世界如此辽阔。见bell hooks入
The only way to attain true equality is to topple all the existing power structures of race , class and the sex so that only oppression or domination is eliminated.⭐️
大学接触的第一批黑人女性文学，把我从白人男性自我怜悯酸楚可怜的男子气概文学中解救出来，影响我到现在。🕯️
很棒的black feminism入门读物，不过历史故事比较多，理论少了点
偶尔读着会有疑惑，觉得史实论据充分吗，这个结论武断吗
从黑人女性视角看待美国近现代女权运动，分析女权、种族和阶级议题相互交缠的复杂关系，有些观点很有意思，但行文可以再简洁一些，车轱辘话翻来覆去说，看得有点疲劳，结构也可以再清晰一点。
hook’s definition of feminism: it is a commitment to eradicating the ideology of domination that permeates Western culture on various levels—”sex, race, and class, to name a few—and a commitment to reorganizing U.S. society so that the self-development of people can take precedence over imperialism, economic expansion, and material desires. (19岁的写作
补标
求书
收藏