How Enemies Become Friends

Charles A. Kupchan

出版时间

2010-02-13

ISBN

9780691142654

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Is the world destined to suffer endless cycles of conflict and war? Can rival nations become partners and establish a lasting and stable peace? How Enemies Become Friends provides a bold and innovative account of how nations escape geopolitical competition and replace hostility with friendship. Through compelling analysis and rich historical examples that span the globe and range from the thirteenth century through the present, foreign policy expert Charles Kupchan explores how adversaries can transform enmity into amity--and he exposes prevalent myths about the causes of peace.

Kupchan contends that diplomatic engagement with rivals, far from being appeasement, is critical to rapprochement between adversaries. Diplomacy, not economic interdependence, is the currency of peace; concessions and strategic accommodation promote the mutual trust needed to build an international society. The nature of regimes matters much less than commonly thought: countries, including the United States, should deal with other states based on their foreign policy behavior rather than on whether they are democracies. Kupchan demonstrates that similar social orders and similar ethnicities, races, or religions help nations achieve stable peace. He considers many historical successes and failures, including the onset of friendship between the United States and Great Britain in the early twentieth century, the Concert of Europe, which preserved peace after 1815 but collapsed following revolutions in 1848, and the remarkably close partnership of the Soviet Union and China in the 1950s, which descended into open rivalry by the 1960s.

In a world where conflict among nations seems inescapable, How Enemies Become Friends offers critical insights for building lasting peace.

Charles A. Kupchan is professor of international affairs at Georgetown University and senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. He served on the National Security Council during the Clinton presidency and is the author of The End of the American Era (Knopf).

目录
List of Illustrations ix
Acknowledgments xi
CHAPTER ONE Stable Peace 1
CHAPTER TWO From International Anarchy to International Society 16
CHAPTER THREE Anglo-American Rapprochement 73

显示全部
用户评论
很多关心的议题都有了初步的处理
倒不是案例选取太随意,主要是这几个步骤有点拍脑门,我不理解单方妥协如何演变成相互克制。。。
相当好的书。书的格式非常想博士论文,但是又比博士论文生动。学习过程中还可以休闲。
那时候在庆应大学做硕士论文阅读过的著作。感觉唐世平老师在他的world politic上的论文已经论及了此书一部分的缺点。严肃地来说,其实此书并不非常值得一读,作者写书似乎相当的随意,从一个模糊的概念出发,然后搜集了一些案例,然后想到哪里写到哪里,最后成书出版。大概对于一般实务工作者,不是没有启发的吧,至少就国际政治这门阴暗的科学而言,所谓国家间利益冲突不可避,冲突与合作之间分分合合,这种宿命论(作者并没有挑战宿命论,但是指出了悲观主义是不对的)的修正而言,大概还是有一定好处的。作者指出,分手也不是没有复合的可能,至少从这一点而言,无论给人的幻想还是希望,还是很有用处的
导致稳定和平的逻辑机制阐述不够明晰,causal factors和process之间的关系模糊;cultural commonality作为重要概念并没有在案例中得到清晰展示;以敌人作为出发点,但许多案例国家之间起初并不具有完全敌对关系;union的演进具有特殊性(rest on small scale and high level of homogeneity),不适合作为最终的演化形态。不过政治先于经济、大国先低头、社会融合可能起反作用的观点还是很有意思的。
收藏