Young China - Mingwei Song

Young China

Mingwei Song

出版时间

2016-01-18

ISBN

9780674088399

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

The rise of youth is among the most dramatic stories of modern China. Since the last years of the Qing dynasty, youth has been made a new agent of history in Chinese intellectuals’ visions of national rejuvenation through such tremendously popular notions as “young China” and “new youth.” The characterization of a young protagonist with a developmental story has also shaped the modern Chinese novel. Young China takes youth as a central literary motif that was profoundly related to the ideas of nationhood and modernity in twentieth-century China. A synthesis of narrative theory and cultural history, it combines historical investigations of the origin and development of the modern Chinese youth discourse with close analyses of the novelistic construction of the Chinese Bildungsroman, which depicts the psychological growth of youth with a symbolic allusion to national rejuvenation. Negotiating between self and society, ideal and action, and form and reality, such a narrative manifests as well as complicates the various political and cultural symbolisms invested in youth through different periods of modern Chinese history. In this story of young China, the restless, elusive, and protean image of youth both perpetuates and problematizes the ideals of national rejuvenation.

Mingwei Song is Associate Professor of Chinese Language and Literature at Wellesley College.

目录
List of Illustrations
Acknowledgments
Prologue: The Beginning of the Journey
1. “Green Spring” and Its Modern Forms: An Introduction to Youth Discourse
2. The Adventures of Old Youth: Late Qing Travelers and Reformers

显示全部
用户评论
以点带面把文学主体的小我和国家政治主体的大我(们)的重影从文本中拉出来,晚晴部分显得单薄了,有大量的时政报论没有引入,更多是为了“少年中国”的民族国家之路做铺垫。对巴金、茅盾的分析可圈可点。
将小说中的青年形象与国家的复兴历史背景对照。
青年的象征建构和成长的叙事展开;倚重巴赫金、卢卡奇、莫雷蒂对于成长小说和现代性的批评,但往往在讨论中强调中国成长叙事的inconclusiveness而不是closure
之前很为这本书的问题意识折服。后来系统读钱理群作品时发现钱老1994年有一篇文章叫《青春是可怕的》,反倒讲得更清楚了一些。 这本书对40年代的开掘是不足够的,结尾遽然引入科幻也算是夹带私货。所以客观讲,这本书的贡献还是主要在20/30年代借叶圣陶、茅盾、巴金的小说文本讲出来的故事。
外国人眼中的新中国
Youth是个重要的意象,20世纪以来的文学例子数不胜数,因为繁多且有重叠,分析起来也难免重复,思想上的重复也表现在语言上。但本书最需要加强的地方,可能是对已有研究的介入(intervention),尤其是批评。
epilogue
似乎还是太聚焦于Bildungsroman所强调的“自我实现”,重心落在forever on the road的forever所提示的主体成长的“未完成性”上,把new youth在历史过程中始终没有彻底自我实现的那个“未完成性”作为一种预想的理论结果加以建构,论述最后还是在诸如interiority和externality,lyricism和history,self和society种种二元对立范式内打转。事实上,就书中所着力引述的40年代长篇小说里的人物,其“成长”的道路可能未必那么“永远未完成”,方向感还是相对明晰的,因而把鹿桥和路翎放在一起对读似乎不是太合适。相对照地,王璞在《读书》上写的书评反而把“青春中国”的问题提升了不少。
收藏