The Swerve

Stephen Greenblatt

出版时间

2011-09-25

ISBN

9780393064476

评分

★★★★★

内容简介

这本获普利策奖的书,核心其实极简单:一位十四世纪的抄书人从图书馆架子上抽出一本被遗忘近千年的古罗马诗稿,觉得它值得抄录,于是卢克修斯的《论事物的本质》得以幸存,并悄然改变了思想史的走向。作者把

作者简介

Stephen Greenblatt (Ph.D. Yale) is Cogan University Professor of the Humanities at Harvard University. Also General Editor of The Norton Anthology of English Literature, he is the author of eleven books, including Tyrant, The Rise and Fall of Adam and Eve: The Story that Created Us, The Swerve: How the World Became Modern (winner of the 2011 National Book Award and the 2012 Pulitzer Prize); Shakespeare's Freedom; Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare; Hamlet in Purgatory; Marvelous Possessions: The Wonder of the New World; Learning to Curse: Essays in Early Modern Culture; and Renaissance Self-Fashioning: From More to Shakespeare. He has edited seven collections of criticism, including Cultural Mobility: A Manifesto, and is a founding coeditor of the journal Representations. His honors include the MLA’s James Russell Lowell Prize, for both Shakespearean Negotiations: The Circulation of Social Energy in Renaissance England and The Swerve, the Sapegno Prize, the Distinguished Humanist Award from the Mellon Foundation, the Wilbur Cross Medal from the Yale University Graduate School, the William Shakespeare Award for Classical Theatre, the Erasmus Institute Prize, two Guggenheim Fellowships, and the Distinguished Teaching Award from the University of California, Berkeley. He was president of the Modern Language Association of America and is a fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the American Philosophical Society, and the American Academy of Arts and Letters. http://stephengreenblatt.com

AI 导读

核心看点
  • 本书获普利策奖,讲述15世纪教廷书记官波焦在修道院偶然发现卢克莱修《物性论》手稿,这一事件如何打破中世纪思想禁锢,推动文艺复兴并奠定现代科学理性基础的历史过程。
  • 作者格林布拉特运用新历史主义方法,细致还原15世纪欧洲政治、宗教与文化生态,展现古典文献在修道院中艰难保存、被重新发掘的曲折历程,揭示知识传承的脆弱性与偶然性。
  • 书中深入探讨伊壁鸠鲁哲学中关于原子论、灵魂随肉体消亡、死亡并非恐怖等激进观点,分析这些思想如何挑战教会权威,促使人类从对来世的恐惧转向关注现世幸福与理性探索。
读者共识
  • 读者普遍认可作者文笔优美、博学多才,叙事流畅且具感染力,能生动再现历史场景与人物心理,尽管部分情节重复啰嗦,但整体阅读体验良好,被视为了解文艺复兴思想起源的优质入门读物。
  • 多数读者批评作者过度拔高波焦发现手稿的历史意义,认为其将复杂历史进程简化为单一事件,逻辑牵强且缺乏学术严谨性,存在哗众取宠之嫌,对现代性起源的解释过于片面且欧洲中心主义。
  • 尽管存在争议,读者仍肯定本书在普及古典哲学与历史知识方面的价值,认为其激发了对伊壁鸠鲁主义及理性思维的兴趣,虽非严谨学术专著,但作为大众历史读物仍具启发意义与阅读价值。

精彩摘录

  • "With his contrasting vision of anxious, work-obsessed, overly disciplined Italians and happy-go-lucky, carefree Germans..."
  • "When the newly elected bishop of Hildesheim, in the north of Germany, asked to see the diocesan library, he was brought to the armory and shown the pikes and battleaxes hanging on the walls; these, he was informed, were the books with which the rights of the bishopric had been won and must be defend"
  • "At first the copying was probably done in an improvised setting in the cloister...But in time special rooms were designated or built for the purpose...these were large rooms equipped with clear glass windows under which the monks, as many as thirty of them, sat at individual desks, sometimes partiti"
  • ""He shall be compelled to read." It was this compulsion that, through centuries of chaos, helped to salvage the achievements of ancient thought."
  • "Good parchment was far too valuable and scarce to be discarded. This value helps to account for the fact that monasteries collected ancient manuscripts in the first place and did not consign them to the rubbish."
  • "我们害怕未来的灾难,害怕陷入持续的痛苦和焦虑之中,因为害怕变得悲惨,我们从来没有停止过这样的生活,总是渴望财富,从来没有给我们的灵魂或身体片刻的 安宁。但那些满足于日常生活的人,把任何一天都当作节日。"
  • "所有其他的诉求一一服务于国家、神灵或统治者的荣耀,通过自我牺牲对美德的艰苦追求一一是次要的、误导或欺诈性的。"
  • "塞拉皮翁垮台之后,一位异教诗人帕拉达斯(Pallads)表达了他黯然伤神的心情: 我们真的死了吗; 还是只活在表面, 我们希腊人,陷入灾难 生活如梦,既然我们还活着, 而我们的生活方式已然逝去? 毁灭的意义,如帕拉达斯所理解的,不仅仅是一个用于拜的偶像的消失。在这种情况下,这次大破坏是否殃及图书馆尚不清楚。但图书馆、博物馆和学校是脆弱的机构:它们无法在暴力的攻击下长期存留。一种生活方式正在消亡"

读者评论

优美 好读
前半段五星,后三分之一三星。lucretius的影响力是核心论点,可把文艺复兴和启蒙运动归结到一首诗实在讲不通,只能帮助理解伊拉斯谟,moore和蒙田的共同传统。书好看的部分就是铺垫部分,变革前夜的教廷,人文学者的痴迷和失落,文字和那个时代一样充满可能性。
It is of great pleasure to read this book, written in such beautiful english and the arguments are well articulated in the well-constructed logic.
epicurean
写完这周的作业之后终于终于终于可以摆脱它了!!!必须发条庆祝一下!!我好讨厌它哦,废话好多,一件事情翻来覆去地能说个好几遍。而且很多结论都好夸张啊,根本就是为了写畅销书然后就乱来了啊。。。。。到底为什么会拿奖阿!!为什么!!
Read in about 2013. My literature professor recommended to me. It’s a great inspiration and I “converted” myself into an Epicurean.
雅俗之间的度把握得挺好的,文献爬梳得也挺细致。很大的一点收获是知道了亚历山大图书馆的始末,完全不是以前看的古代典籍被穆斯林一把火烧了的故事
以十五世纪的人文学者意大利人文学者Poggio Bracciolini重新发现卢克莱修的《物性论》,其中蕴藏的伊壁鸠鲁哲学为现代思想奠基的故事作为主线,兼及Poggio在教廷和佛罗伦萨的政治生涯、古典的衰落与其在修道院的保留等时代侧面。书读起来并不很激动人心,以其大叙事来说,是对于“现代”最“经典”也最局限的一种理解:欧洲中心、中世纪/文艺复兴对立...也许是面向大众的书写限制了更近一步的学理思考,但文辞确实优美。
文艺复兴的历史沿革讲述的不错 epicurus派对欧洲影响很大
仿佛在读一本扣人心弦的thriller,Poggio Bracciolini将Lucretius的On the Nature of Things从修道院中拯救出来的那一刻简直激动人心。从一个微小时刻为轴,牵引出许多内容,如Epicureanism最初的形成及后来的影响,罗马至中世纪前期的卷轴、书本、抄写、保存,Epicureanism如何在中世纪早期被教会一步步瓦解而不为人知,文艺复兴时期意大利城邦、罗马教廷的文化氛围等。
全部深度解读 →主题书单高分榜最近更新