Shaken Authority - Christian P. Sorace

Shaken Authority

Christian P. Sorace

出版时间

2017-05-09

ISBN

9781501707537

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

In Shaken Authority, Christian P. Sorace examines the political mechanisms at work in the aftermath of the 2008 Sichuan earthquake and the broader ideological energies that drove them. Sorace takes Communist Party ideas and discourse as central to how that organization formulates policies, defines legitimacy, and exerts its power. Sorace argues that the Communist Party has never abandoned its conviction that discourse can shape the world and the people who inhabit it. Sorace also demonstrates how the Communist Party's planning apparatus continues to play a crucial role in engineering China’s economy and market construction, especially in the countryside. Sorace takes a distinctive and original interpretive approach to understanding Chinese politics, and Shaken Authority demonstrates how Communist Party discourse and ideology influenced the official decisions and responses to the Sichuan earthquake. Sorace provides a clear view of the lived outcomes of Communist Party plans, rationalities, and discourses in the earthquake zone. The three case studies he presents each demonstrate a different type of reconstruction and model of development: urban-rural integration, tourism, and ecological civilization. Sorace’s work emphasizes the need for a grounded literacy in the political concepts, discourses, and vocabularies of the Communist Party itself. To dismiss China’s official discourse as "empty propaganda," Sorace argues, makes China and Chinese realities harder to understand, not easier.

Christian P. Sorace is a Post-Doctoral Fellow at the Australian National University's Centre on China in the World.

目录
Introduction
1. The Communist Party's Miracle
2. Party Spirit Made Flesh
3. Blood Transfusion, Generation, and Anemia
4. The Utopia of Urban Planning

显示全部
用户评论
fieldwork做得让人眼前一亮
提供了蛮丰富的田野资料,如何从灾祸话语转为重建、转为感恩。不知道该说CCP是擅长这些还是熟能生巧……
第二章讲"党性” 公务员白加黑心理压力大有些干部自杀 很多自杀的官员的理由肯定是不会跟这个外国人讲的 但是挖掘得已经比较地道了
以汶川地震灾后重建为例,分析了我CPC的“国难”话语模式。。。和现在这情形倒也贴合
危机是对权威合法性的震动,但也在提醒人民他们的生命和生活都依赖党的权威而存在。震动的根源在于党出于政治和美学理性的规划与人民的经济生活之间的不一致,无论是乌托邦式的城市化观念,还是美学主导的灾后旅游经济和生态文明建设,都体现出这种脱节。权威做出的反应是以感恩教育的形式强化意识形态中人民对党的依赖,但这种感恩教育依赖于党对干部予取予求,后者在党性原则下做出无限的牺牲。本书强调意识形态的重要性,因为经济支撑合法性的论点并不能解释人民如何理解自己的经济生活,而感恩教育的本质正是要重塑人民对自己经济生活与党国之间关系的理解。然而后四章基本都是例子的堆积,除了说明了这种重塑的局限性之外,并没有拓展两章提出的框架,深入的话语分析做得也意外地少。2020.8.28
每一次的危机都是对党的合法性的一次考验。
Party Propaganda那一套话语内地读者想必都不会陌生,但此书点出了其背后的assumption和意图,个人很受chapter 3启发,都江堰、映秀和青川的案例很有趣。和当年在四川调研所见类似,村里家家户户房子修得很好,但临近春节仍只有老弱妇孺,十分荒凉,本地没有机会,年轻人都外出打工了,老年贫困很普遍。总体来说可读性很强,不是太学术.
收藏