Just the Arguments - Bruce, Michael; Barbone, Steven;

Just the Arguments

Bruce, Michael; Barbone, Steven;

出版时间

2011-10-03

ISBN

9781444336382

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Does the existence of evil call into doubt the existence of God? Show me the argument. Philosophy starts with questions, but attempts at answers are just as important, and these answers require reasoned argument. Cutting through dense philosophical prose, 100 famous and influential arguments are presented in their essence, with premises, conclusions and logical form plainly identified. Key quotations provide a sense of style and approach. Just the Arguments is an invaluable one-stop argument shop. * A concise, formally structured summation of 100 of the most important arguments in Western philosophy* The first book of its kind to present the most important and influential philosophical arguments in a clear premise/conclusion format, the language that philosophers use and students are expected to know* Offers succinct expositions of key philosophical arguments without bogging them down in commentary* Translates difficult texts to core arguments* Designed to provides a quick and compact reference to everything from Aquinas' “Five Ways" to prove the existence of God, to the metaphysical possibilities of a zombie world* Visit www.justthearguments.com, the editor's site for students, teachers, researchers, and fans of philosophy

用户评论
比《西方哲学史》的教材强81237126752346894239930218901290倍。
真不戳
只读了第四部分,论证小巧清晰,但因篇幅限制也不够深入,作为导读性质的分析论证还是非常不错的。个人觉得leveling down argument against egalitarianism 与liberal feminism两节比较有耳目一新的感觉。
p150“ The question for the contextualist is whether these systems of mutually supporting beliefs have anything to do with the truth··· problem” for coherentism.”这里“contextualist”或应该为“coherentist” p130“C3. No given state of affairs can deterministically cause a human action ( modus tollens, P1, C3)”中最后一个“C3”或应改为C2(@秋擎指出)
非常棒,虽然琐碎,但是很清晰。
收藏