P.S. I Still Love You
出版时间
2015-05-26
ISBN
9781442426733
评分
★★★★★
书籍介绍
这是《P.S. I Love You》的续篇，也是整部三部曲里口碑最分裂的一本。它把镜头对准了那个始终没能上位的John——那个认真权衡每个人优点、迟迟下不了决心的男孩。读者几乎齐刷刷地为他抱不平：有人干脆喊话“直接男二上位不香吗”。也正因如此，这本书真正值得聊的，不是浪漫结局，而是那个“和前任纠缠不清”的男主该如何收场。作者没有给出爽快的答案，而是让主角在动摇与深爱之间反复拉扯，把“love can go away, or people can, without even meaning to”的无力感写得格外真切。它适合那些愿意接受“不完美结局”的读者：如果你期待第一部的轻盈圆满，这里或许会让你觉得仓促；但如果你在乎的是成长里那些无法保证、只能冒险的部分，它会让你想起那句“want it all, you have to risk it all”。
AI导读
核心看点
- 本书聚焦于主角Lara Jean在经历情感背叛后的心理重建过程，深入探讨信任破裂后的痛苦与修复。作者Jenny Han细腻刻画了主角在道德困境中的挣扎，展现了青少年面对复杂人际关系时的无助与成长，强调情感伤害并非简单的对错，而是需要时间与自我接纳来疗愈。
- 书中涉及对前女友Genevieve的复杂态度转变，从怨恨到试图理解其家庭悲剧背景，这一情节引发巨大争议。作者试图通过展现角色的多面性来打破刻板印象，但部分读者认为这种‘洗白’处理过于牵强，削弱了主角立场的正当性，反映了创作中平衡角色深度与读者情绪的难题。
- 故事穿插了关于死亡、失去与成长的严肃议题，主角在亲人离世后的哀悼过程描写得较为深刻。然而，浪漫主线因主角与前任纠缠不清、缺乏边界感而备受诟病，许多读者批评主角在情感上的优柔寡断和不忠诚，认为其处理方式幼稚且令人不适，整体观感不如系列第一部。
读者共识
- 读者普遍认为本书是系列中最弱的一部，浪漫情节令人尴尬且主角行为不可爱。大量评论批评主角对前任纠缠不清、缺乏边界感，认为其处理方式幼稚且不负责任。许多读者表示对主角产生反感，认为其不配得到男主的包容，整体观感糟糕，不建议未读第一部者直接阅读。
- 关于前女友Genevieve的‘洗白’情节引发巨大争议，多数读者认为作者强行赋予其同情分，忽视了其行为的伤害性。读者批评这种处理削弱了主角立场的正当性，认为这是对受害者的二次伤害。尽管部分读者认可角色复杂性，但主流意见认为这种和解缺乏逻辑支撑，令人难以接受。
- 尽管浪漫线备受诟病，部分读者仍认可书中关于死亡、失去与成长的描写具有深度。有读者指出，主角最终学会告别过去、接受不完美的过程具有教育意义。但总体而言，负面评价占主导，读者共识是本书质量下滑，建议跳过或仅作批判性阅读，不推荐作为青春爱情小说的典范。
精彩摘录
- "People come in and out of your life. For a time they are your world; They are everything. And then one day they're not. There's no telling how long you will have them near."
- "Things feel like they will be forever, but they aren't. Love can go away, or people can, without even meaning to. Nothing is guaranteed."
- "I know now that I don't want to love or to be loved in half measures. I want it all, and to have it all, you have yo risk it all."
- "There's no way to protect yourself against heartbreak, Lara Jean. That's just part of life."
- "All you need is time, and you, little one, have all the time in the world."
- "Feminist? ""Stormy makes a disgusted sound in her throat I' m no feminist. Really, Lara Jean! "Stormy, don’t get worked up about it. All it means is that you believe men and women are equal, and should have equal rights I dont think any man is my equal. Women are far superior. and don't you forget i"
- "We hang up soon after, and even though I feel better about the video. I still feel unsettled about Peter. I know he's upset about not being able to protect me, but I also know that part of why he's upset is because his pride was injured, and that has nothing to do with me. Is a boy's ego really such"
- "John took a long time to decide. He went around the circle, weighing all of our merits. Peter was a fast runner, Trevor was strong, Genevieve was crafty, Chris could handle herself in a fight, and for me he said I would never give up hope of being rescued. So he picked me."
用户评论
不如第一本，结局好仓促，poor John
Lara Jean也太幸福了吧 她喜欢过的直男都喜欢她啊OTZ 十分不喜欢给Gen洗白的方式，她和LJ早年的塑料友谊让我一脸懵逼…书里还有音乐之声和大悲的reference，看到Cosette和Eponine的时候脑内自动响起a heart full of love😂最后…………John不要给我好不好！！！！！！！
总体啰嗦…但John太甜了QAQpeter886吧
John真的是标准男二 最后结尾原谅Peter和gen有点仓促
第二本感觉不用读了，随便听听就算过了。正好A家会员送一个月Audible Escape试用，包含这个三部曲。各种小细节依旧细心，总体感觉不如第一部。
同前一部 感觉看到这也够了
第二本 封神 又俗又好笑
这一本情节还是蛮naive..全书最后一页的歌单最佳！
这个结局真是wtf？？？？？？？？？？？被bully到这个程度还能选择原谅我真的替所有被霸凌过女孩感到心酸。自己的父亲出轨=可以合理霸凌别人？fuck peter and fuck gen, lara jean you really deserve better.
本来买来想看了书再去看电影的，结果还是先看了电影。然鹅，好喜欢这本的文字，以及电影里删掉的assassin game。途中哭了两次。很中我意。
Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers的其他书籍查看全部
下载
收藏