The Ideological Foundations of Qing Taxation - Taisu Zhang

The Ideological Foundations of Qing Taxation

Taisu Zhang

出版时间

2022-11-30

ISBN

9781108995955

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

How states develop the capacity to tax is a question of fundamental importance to political science, legal theory, economics, sociology, and history. Increasingly, scholars believe that China's relative economic decline in the 18th and 19th centuries was related to its weak fiscal institutions and limited revenue. This book argues that this fiscal weakness was fundamentally ideological in nature. Belief systems created through a confluence of traditional political ethics and the trauma of dynastic change imposed unusually deep and powerful constraints on fiscal policymaking and institutions throughout the final 250 years of China's imperial history. Through the Qing example, this book combs through several interaction dynamics between state institutions and ideologies. The latter shapes the former, but the former can also significantly reinforce the political durability of the latter. In addition to its historical analysis of ideological politics, this book makes a major contribution to the longstanding debate on Sino-European divergence.

Taisu Zhang is Professor of Law and History at Yale University.

用户评论
比他第一本好
前两天为了博士资格考,在导师的要求下,连夜把这书读完了。四百多页,读完还是挺累的。这几年读过的所有史学著作里(是的,这本书归根到底还是史学著作,而且抛开唯一一章的纯理论内容,其实还挺正统的),这是思维力度最强的一本。不光对宏观历史问题给出了相当有说服力的新解释,而且真的有理论贡献。从信息制度的角度分析意识形态的政治寿命,以前确实没见过,即使是在政治理论著作里。
⭐️⭐️⭐️💫。问题意识强。前三章略显的车轱辘话的论述确实也能让人记住问题。rationalist对清代农业税的二百年停滞的解释有道理,但,恰恰相反的是(張師惯用句式),又不能解释非农业税的增加。同意意识形态对农业税的水平的维持有作用,但仅从明面上的税收和估计的informal tax来讨论清朝的财政危机和纾困在今天可能已经不具十足的说服力,除了增加non- agricultural tax,大量的捐纳可能是更方便快捷的增收纾困途径?经济方面的统计主要还是建立在已有的文献上。PS,p236 Li Ba應為 Li Fu李紱… and Li Fu became Guangxi governor in early Yongzheng reign, not late Kangxi
我欣赏本书的Theoretical framework。依我浅见,本书的理论与Elizabeth Anderson关于the epistemology of justice的理论有异曲同工之妙。然而,至少第三章存在不容忽视的史实错误,甚至可能影响作者一些立论。
没见识的我一边苦于本书的信息密度,一边读着惊掉嘴巴
:)
请问怎么获得这本书呀
蛮好的书,作者视野开阔
收藏