Tying the Autocrat's Hands

Wang Yuhua

出版时间

2014-12-18

ISBN

9781107071742

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Under what conditions would authoritarian rulers be interested in the rule of law? What type of rule of law exists in authoritarian regimes? How do authoritarian rulers promote the rule of law without threatening their grip on power? Tying the Autocrat's Hands answers these questions by examining legal reforms in China. Yuhua Wang develops a demand-side theory arguing that authoritarian rulers will respect the rule of law when they need the cooperation of organized interest groups that control valuable and mobile assets but are not politically connected. He also defines the rule of law that exists in authoritarian regimes as a partial form of the rule of law, in which judicial fairness is respected in the commercial realm but not in the political realm. Tying the Autocrat's Hands demonstrates that the rule of law is better enforced in regions with a large number of foreign investors but less so in regions heavily invested in by Chinese investors.

目录
1. Introduction
2. A demand-side theory of authoritarian rule of law
3. Authoritarian judiciary: how the party-state limits the rule of law
4. State-business relations in China
5. Who bribes?

显示全部
用户评论
未达到预期。单看标题便能知核心论点的关键——外资进入推动中国经济领域的法治,但政治体制决定了政府不会允许政治上的防治。观点似乎不新鲜,且对于法治的探讨不够深入。被看重的或许更多的是多方法和数据处理的擅长吧。
非常喜欢
裕华老师粉丝滤镜+1星
时过境迁,但理论框架还算有效…
一些结论:外资企业由于没有政治资本、受企业机制不会贿赂,普遍认为自身产权没有受到保护,转而寻求法治途径、走诉讼而非调解或仲裁。对比之下港澳台资本因有人际网络而无意推动法治,中国经济改革是外资vs中资而非公有vs私有。政府为FDI经济利益相应建设法制,但仅限于经济纠纷而非民事/政治纠纷。法院行政结构、经费来源、人员晋升直接说受控于政府,后者又看重经济发展和社会稳定,所以法庭直接成了维持绩效的工具。作者为了出书时常一段话在前中后反复说三五遍让我很困扰,而且这种以定量方法为主导的铁板一块的研究显然太无趣、结论太大一统了,让我怀疑定性访谈的其他自变量都不见了,每章开头引一段卡夫卡的城堡很文艺,不过总体而言我对法治需求侧理论不感兴趣,顺道八卦了他统计学家老婆Boyang Chai~ Chris
我觉得还可以,虽然观点老套但回答了那本讲新加坡威权式法治的书没有回答的问题。rule of law是在商业领域,为了吸引投资,而在政治领域则不然。我觉得作者把大陆的法律系统讲的还是挺透彻的,尽管很多东西我早先已经知晓但也还是能读到一些知识增量,不过我对于量化的东西真的完全不了解。
有用,有点没意思。
insight, methodology, and impressive words. "To make the rule of law complete, autocrats not only need to tie their hands but also have to dig their own graves to make democratic transitions."
大二读过
收藏