Authentic Replicas - Hsueh-man Shen

Authentic Replicas

Hsueh-man Shen

出版时间

2018-10-30

ISBN

9780824867058

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

As belief in the Buddha grew and his teachings were transmitted across Asia, Buddhist images, scriptures, and relics were duplicated and reduplicated to satisfy the needs of increasing numbers of the faithful. Yet how were these countless copies of sacred objects able to retain their authenticity and efficacy? Authentic Replicas explores how Buddhists in medieval China (seventh to twelfth centuries) solved this conundrum through the use of traditional methods of replication such as stamping, mold casting, and woodblock printing to create objects that fulfilled the spiritual aspirations of those who possessed them. Setting aside Western notions about the relative value of copies versus the “original,” the book posits Buddhist ideas on what imbues an object with credibility and authority and offers fresh insights into the ways authenticity was represented and reproduced in the Chinese Buddhist context.

Each section of the volume focuses on an area of artistic output to provide readers with a thorough grasp of the theological concepts underpinning each act of duplication. Part I looks at the replication of sutras to clarify how the spiritual value of a handwritten sutra differed from a printed one. In Part II, clay tablets, woodblock prints, silk paintings, and cave murals are examined to trace iconographic lineages and uncover the divine identity in each new replica. The chapters in Part III describe in detail the copying of the Buddha’s bodily relics and the endlessly repeated votive act of burying these in stupas. Of particular significance is the visual and textual vocabulary used on reliquaries to persuade adherents to believe in the actual presence of the Buddha concealed inside.

Deftly weaving together data and research from several disciplines, including Buddhist studies, archaeology, and art history, Authentic Replicas vividly conveys how replication lay at the heart of Buddhist worship in medieval China, offering a new understanding of how religious belief guided the artistic output of an entire age.

Hsueh-man Shen is Associate Professor: Ehrenkranz Chair in World Art at the Institute of Fine Arts, New York University.

用户评论
基本是雷德侯的module理论在中古佛教艺术上的应用和延伸。为了说明replication的广泛存在,选择案例时覆盖了非常广的范围,负面效果是没有足够的context。另外前两章似乎过于依赖文献,不太像是艺术史写作...
😑
总有一种作者在藏拙的感觉…
读罢,大概了解友邻们为何对这本书差评居多。实际上佛教的replication对西方概念中的mass production(尤其是现当代)可以有很多有意思的回应,本以为作者可以更深入去讨论replication和authenticity/originality的关系,但作者更多只是借replica之名去讲述一些已经被熟知的东西(merit,replication的产物有哪些,哪些地方可以看到replication,仅此而已,跟authenticity之间有什么关系?一点讨论都没有),论述常常没有说服力,感觉作者没有处理好modular thinking/production、standardization、variation和uniqueness的关系,常常出现概念使用的混淆。
去年作者来学校讲座没去,深以为憾。 authentic replicas 的概念的提出很精妙,对西方美术史的反思也十分直接。能够重新审视已经研究过很多次的材料,完整的研究观看方式,制作方式,展览和收藏方式:一本很令人心生敬意的研究。
收藏