Hegel, Haiti, and Universal History - Susan Buck-Morss

Hegel, Haiti, and Universal History

Susan Buck-Morss

出版时间

2009-02-28

ISBN

9780822959786

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

In this path-breaking work, Susan Buck-Morss draws new connections between history, inequality, social conflict, and human emancipation. "Hegel, Haiti, and Universal History" offers a fundamental reinterpretation of Hegel's master-slave dialectic and points to a way forward to free critical theoretical practice from the prison-house of its own debates. Historicizing the thought of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel and the actions taken in the Haitian Revolution, Buck-Morss examines the startling connections between the two and challenges us to widen the boundaries of our historical imagination. She finds that it is in the discontinuities of historical flow, the edges of human experience, and the unexpected linkages between cultures that the possibility to transcend limits is discovered. It is these flashes of clarity that open the potential for understanding in spite of cultural differences. What Buck-Morss proposes amounts to a "new humanism," one that goes beyond the usual ideological implications of such a phrase to embrace a radical neutrality that insists on the permeability of the space between opposing sides and as it reaches for a common humanity.

Susan Buck-Morss is Jan Rock Zubrow Ô77 Chair of Social Sciences, and professor of political philosophy and social theory in the department of government at Cornell University. She is the author of Thinking Past Terror: Islamism and Critical Theory on the Left, Dreamworld and Catastrophe: The Passing of Mass Utopia in East and West, The Dialectics of Seeing: Walter Benjamin and...

(展开全部)

用户评论
本觉得写奴隶制和全球史很cliche,但却读出很多新意,尤其是把这么明目张胆拉进来,还时不时抖个机灵,也算是老树开新花。
真的厉害...
imagination that transcend boundaries
读了Hegel and Haiti部分。why is it important to ask the question about Hegel and Haiti? not only to expose the academic bad faith and compartmentalization in contemporary academia, but to note that the master-slave dialectic is a living process of history that is constantly available and could be applied almost infinitely
160902 | 前一半提出了好问题,然而后一半的讨论较为令人失望
得想个办法把长书评发出来// 我非常同情作者的立场 但为她在学术上的高度不严谨感到惋惜
感觉mind-blowing but historiographically unsound…正像作者本人说的,”a mystery story.”
从海地大革命来看黑格尔主奴辩证法,作者想要指出的是黑格尔明知道海地发生的奴隶的二次斗争是存在且现实的,却依然讲奴隶的出路在于改造自然,追求的自由的方式是斯多葛主义式的自欺,而非革命。然而作者遗忘的却是海地革命的前提是启蒙运动所倡导的人权和平等,而非古希腊的城邦现实中的公民自由,移置历史背景在黑格尔看来会导致精神现象学中严谨的精神发展逻辑的紊乱,从而黑格尔所看重的历史性也就无从谈起了。
收藏