书籍 Teachers of the Inner Chambers的封面

Teachers of the Inner Chambers

Dorothy Ko

出版时间

1995-01-01

ISBN

9780804723596

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Rejecting popular image and accepted scholarship on the status of women in premodern China, this pathbreaking work argues that literate gentrywomen in seventeenth-century Jiangnan were far from oppressed or silenced. As writers, readers, editors, and teachers, these women created a rich culture and meaningful existence from within the constraints of the male-dominated Confucian system. The author reconstructs the social, emotional, and intellectual worlds of these women from the interstices between ideology, practice, and self-perception. Born out of curiosity about how premodern Chinese women lived, this book proposes a new way to conceptualize China's past. This reconception rests on the premise that by understanding how women lived, we better grasp the dynamics of gender relations and gain a more complete knowledge of the values of Chinese culture, the functioning of Chinese society, and the nature of historical change. The book examines three types of women's communities that developed in this environment: domestic, social, and public. Women from different families, age groups, and social stations were brought together by their shared love of poetry and common concerns as women. Though important at the time, most of these ties proved fragile and transitory because of women's inherently ambivalent position. The author argues that the gender system identified women both by their shared gender, or women-as-same, and by their social station, or women-as-different. This contradiction accorded women freedoms within their own limited spheres, but these spheres were fragmented and often demarcated by the class of male kin. As a result, even the most mobile and articulate of women had noinstitutional means of launching fundamental attacks on the gender system.

Professor Ko’s research interest is the everyday lives of women in China –along with the domestic objects they made by hand–as a significant part of country’s cultural, economic and political development. She works at the intersections of anthropology, history, and women’s studies.

Ko’s recent book, Cinderella Sisters: A Revisionist History of Footbinding, published in 2005, sh...

(展开全部)

目录
Frontmatter
Explanatory Notepage xiii
Selected Reign Periods of the Ming and Qing Dynasties, 1522-1795page xv
Map of Jiangnan Areapage xvi
Introduction: Gender and the Politics of Chinese Historypage 1

显示全部
用户评论
A good dissertation book. Less a gender than a revisionist study to present the instrumentality of a historically underrepresented community.
唉。。其实我的兴趣就在性别史,可为什么我一直在写民族主义的论文。。
某种程度上修正得有点过头,当然因为是研究的上层女性,她们因阶级差别享有一定的自由可以理解,但这极少数的女性只能使我们对古代妇女的认识更多样化,不能改变妇女被压迫这一总体的认识。
我手上这一本复印的书,是2002年,高老师在封面上写下书名 她的英文名和出版社的名字,在扉页上给我留了一句话。感怀于心,永志不忘。
其实还是夹缝中生存…我非常喜欢高老师对Bourdieu理论的运用,嗯再加上他对cultural capital的论述,实在是太适合写明末清初的女画家们了……
明清以前的朝代也有过“才女”,但她们在各自的时代里孤独着。明清之际,江南的每一个城镇都有女性写作,她们发表作品也相互交流,给自己开辟了一块新的空间。她们知道自己不再孤单。这一特权仅限于江南地区的上层阶级女性,新的自留地仍是在儒家体制内的探索且固化了父权伦理道德。尽管如此,这是没有窗的屋子里,一阵珍贵的新风。
写作简洁,思路清晰,所有做中国性别史肯定都绕不开dorothy ko
good
作為一本批判“五四女性史觀”的經典之作,此書有兩個缺陷,都跟它的subject matter——明清之際的江南文人階級才女——有關:1. 作者提到的江南才女屬於士紳階級,是否status overruling gender才使得她們比一般平民婦女甚至內陸同階層婦女有更多參與文化生活的機會?2. 作者不斷強調明清之交的社會與政治轉型給了江南閨秀拓展女性空間的機會,那麼是不是可以認為明清朝代更替是個特殊情況,本書中的江南才女只是特殊歷史背景下的temporary transgression?結合Matthew Sommer對清代婚姻與性別的法律研究,雍正改革大大延伸了國家對性規範的治理,Ko書中提到的晚明名妓文化也不復存在。兩個缺陷結合起來,本書是否真正推翻了它意圖批判的“五四女性史觀”?