The Privileged Poor - Anthony Abraham Jack

The Privileged Poor

Anthony Abraham Jack

出版时间

2019-03-01

ISBN

9780674976894

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Getting in is only half the battle. The Privileged Poor reveals how―and why―disadvantaged students struggle at elite colleges, and explains what schools can do differently if these students are to thrive.

The Ivy League looks different than it used to. College presidents and deans of admission have opened their doors―and their coffers―to support a more diverse student body. But is it enough just to admit these students? In The Privileged Poor, Anthony Jack reveals that the struggles of less privileged students continue long after they’ve arrived on campus. Admission, they quickly learn, is not the same as acceptance. This bracing and necessary book documents how university policies and cultures can exacerbate preexisting inequalities and reveals why these policies hit some students harder than others.

Despite their lofty aspirations, top colleges hedge their bets by recruiting their new diversity largely from the same old sources, admitting scores of lower-income black, Latino, and white undergraduates from elite private high schools like Exeter and Andover. These students approach campus life very differently from students who attended local, and typically troubled, public high schools and are often left to flounder on their own. Drawing on interviews with dozens of undergraduates at one of America’s most famous colleges and on his own experiences as one of the privileged poor, Jack describes the lives poor students bring with them and shows how powerfully background affects their chances of success.

If we truly want our top colleges to be engines of opportunity, university policies and campus cultures will have to change. Jack provides concrete advice to help schools reduce these hidden disadvantages―advice we cannot afford to ignore.

Anthony Abraham Jack, a native of Miami, received a scholarship to attend Gulliver Preparatory School, an elite private high school in South Florida. He went on to receive degrees from Amherst College and Harvard University. He is currently a Junior Fellow at the Harvard Society of Fellows, an Assistant Professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, and the Shutzer Assi...

(展开全部)

目录
Abbreviations
Introduction: Can Poor Students Be Privileged?
1. “Come with Me to Italy!”
2. “Can You Sign Your Book for Me?”
3. “I, Too, Am Hungry”

显示全部
用户评论
主要提出了poor students大类里有细分的privileged poor的概念。这些privileged poor因为高中时期进入了更为精英和高层的环境,在进入精英大学之后与peer和校里的adults沟通会更游刃有余,相较于doubly disadvantaged来说。但他们仍旧摆脱不了贫穷带来的物质上的障碍。其中第二章关于与老师、admin staff的交互让人十分能relate。对于doubly disadvantaged来说,是否真的应该宁做鸡头,不做凤尾呢?
https://athenacool.wordpress.com/2019/07/15/the-privileged-poor/
就讲讲故事。没什么洞见。
去听book talk的时候觉得心都碎了。看的时候就反正也心情沉重,还是蛮容易共情double disadvantaged and privileged poor两个贫困学生群体在精英学校面临的各种结构性困境,PP学生因为在私校积累了文化资本能更好地熟练运用institutional resources(office hour, networking, seeking help, at ease with the rich), 但面临金钱相关问题时PP和DD一样无力:spring break famine, 做学生清洁员感受到的区隔和领免费文化活动票时隔开的队伍,一样触目惊心和让人愤怒。也很喜欢Jack写方法memo时候提到没想到强度很高的访谈对他自己来说感情上也非常有挑战。
接着paying for the party 往后写了一下好学校里的穷学生,一种比较幸运,通过各种项目在寄宿学校积累过一轮人力和文化资本,一种实惨,费劲来了以后各种文化冲击。有的时候觉得社会生活太复杂了,即使是穷人也会被同一个社会的不同项目给分裂成几个小群体,产生不一样的体验(作者顺嘴提了一下群体之间对于同一件事不同的道德界限)。观察一下,其实在留学生里也常见,只不过parachute kids吸引了更多的媒体注意力。终于,美国人终于意识到diversity不仅仅是肤色意义上的representative,也能注意到阶级伤害是真实的存在了。
我觉得所有要写DEI statement的人都可以看一下这本书,作者对privileged poor的定义耐人寻味,讲的故事也简单有趣。缺点也是很明显的,作者的质性研究无法回答因果关系的问题,学生在大学的表现和体验有时候未必(直接)来源于PP的状态/他们上了什么样的高中,alienation或者feeling not entitled也有可能是性格因素主导的。有点好奇作者提到的定量研究是怎么设计的,不过猜想过去也只能证明关联性而非因果关系。
逐渐让我回顾起我的高中大学生活,选了一个被所有人忽略的人群切入,点出了一些不被重视的教育场景中和社会中的现象,让我对自己的生活和选择也有了更进一步的理解,inspiring但是有点啰嗦,值得一看
一边流眼泪一边读完这本书,虽然我没在美国读过书,但依然能relate其中的很多故事,尤其是第一次踏入精英大学时所经历的各种culture shock;我对这本书有种相见恨晚的感觉,原来不只是我一个人在大学里感到无所适从,原来我的失败真的是有一定阶级原因在里面的,而不是我自己想象出来的,原来真的有人和我一样被阶级差距所困扰和折磨
已看中文版
被privileged poor这个概念吸引来看的书,看后失望多一些,觉得。。。嗯,好像也没啥啊,因为之前boarding school的经历所以融入精英大学会更容易,这个感觉也不是什么石破天惊的发现啊。。。不过其中有些发现还真的震惊到了我,包括春假期间食堂不开导致的饥饿(甚至有女生会通过dating来寻求免费的饭)
收藏