Is Eating People Wrong? - Allan Hutchinson

Is Eating People Wrong?

Allan Hutchinson

出版时间

2011-01-25

ISBN

9780521188517

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍
Great cases are those judicial decisions around which the common law develops. This book explores eight exemplary cases from the United Kingdom, the United States and Australia that show the law as a living, breathing and down-the-street experience. It explores the social circumstances in which the cases arose and the ordinary people whose stories influenced and shaped the law as well as the characters and institutions (lawyers, judges and courts) that did much of the heavy lifting. By examining the consequences and fallout of these decisions, the book depicts the common law as an experimental, dynamic, messy, productive, tantalizing and bottom-up process, thereby revealing the diverse and uncoordinated attempts by the courts to adapt the law to changing conditions and shifting demands. Great cases are one way to glimpse the workings of the common law as an untidy but stimulating exercise in human judgment and social accomplishment.
精彩摘录
  • "宽忍见证人"
用户评论
普通法导论。相比起从制度逻辑与法律体系出发,Allen C. Hutchinson所提取的是普通法的一个侧面:an experimental, dynamic, messy, productive, tantalizing, and bottom-up process.以八宗判例为核心,尤其展现普通法由下至上的动态运作:a living tradition of dispute resolution——“continuity with the past is only a necessity, not a duty.”引发无数法理学争论的食人案、平权基石布朗案、侵权法里程碑蜗牛案、米兰达案,作为导论而言,重要的不是每个案子判决如何(置于具体部门法脉络中,这很重要),而是普通法的发展足迹。
landmark cases are made via alignment of 天时地利人和 & glamorous on-stage acts often have an ironic behind
精彩。但如果我能10年前阅读就更好了。文青(不是)极度舒适向阅读,恐怖海难案件要提及爱伦坡50年前小说的同名男主,猎狐要提王尔德,无处不在的奥威尔济慈沃霍尔等等小gobbet用意不仅止于炫学,也提醒我们法律如何根植于历史之中,并与文化互相影响塑造。用大篇幅讲案件及主人公们的花边后续而非进行更多严肃法理分析或许会令一些有特定期待的读者失望,但在我眼中这是本书无可取代的长处。不避讳民权抗争会遭致更惨的打击报复,生活也总要继续,绝大多数里程碑案件的主人公下场凄惨甚至有一丝陷入因果过深终被天谴的意味,可能是我辈的永恒宿命吧。总之看完百感交集,对于不会为任何人停留的生活来说,法律如此重要又如此有限
收藏