Vessels - Claudia Brittenham (ed.)

Vessels

Claudia Brittenham (ed.)

出版时间

2019-09-05

ISBN

9780198832577

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Vessels can take many forms: as objects made for human interaction and handling, they both contain and are bounded by space. They can be constructed of a wide variety of materials. But the range of vessels - across history and across cultures - are unified in their potential for practical functioning, whether or not a particular object is in fact made to be used in its particular context.

In this volume, four essays by leading scholars tackle the category of the vessel in a comparative conversation between classical Greece, late antique Rome, pre-Columbian Mesoamerica, and ancient China. By considering the material properties of the object as container, the interactions between user and artefact, and the power of the vessel as both conceptual category and material metaphor, they argue that many vessels - and assemblages of vessels - were sites of remarkable workmanship and considerable ingenuity, smart and sophisticated commentaries on the very categories that they embody.

In placing these individual case studies in dialogue, the volume offers an art historical and cross-cultural study of vessels in ancient societies, considering both objects and their archaeological contexts. Its aim is to make illuminating comparisons, contrasts, and interpretations by juxtaposing traditions. In keeping with the aims of the series, it serves as a model for a new kind of comparative art history, one which emphasizes material culture and is attentive to questions of evidence and method, yet remains historically grounded and contextually sensitive.

Claudia Brittenham is Associate Professor of Art History and the College at the University of Chicago. Her research focuses on the art of Mesoamerica, especially Central Mexico and the Maya area, with particular interests in the materiality of art and the politics of style. She is the author of The Murals of Cacaxtla: The Power of Painting in Ancient Central Mexico (University ...

(展开全部)

目录
Frontmatter
List of Illustrations
List of Contributors
0. Introduction, Claudia Brittenham with Ja^s Elsner
1. Ancient Greek Vessels between Sea, Earth, and Clouds, Richard Neer

显示全部
用户评论
拖延着没读的书再读一本,还是挺满足的。四篇文章都很好看,放在一起互为对照也效果很好,的确能体现Neer在丛书导言里谈到的所谓comparativism of method。很多细处的比照和差异都值得琢磨,编排总体是很成功的。等工作一阵再回头来读丛书里的另两本。
Claudia的引言也写得太好了: "A vessel is not flat.. A vessel is interactive...vessels cry out to be handled, turned, peered into, opened, fondled, eaten from. A vessel exists to connect a human being, its user, to the materials stored inside the object. A vessel is thus always one element of a triangle...No vessel is sui generis..." 简直是替vessels发声的statement。
这一些列丛书思考全球美术史以及比较美术史除了要摆脱区隔一隅、欧洲中心、非连结的美术史观,主要期待还有三点:其一,在本土(emic)和现代学术话语的辩证下,重新思考世界各地美术的基本类型、观念、时空设定,以做更加细致、审慎的古史重建;其二,重新思考古今的观看(beholding)模式,谁在看、看什么、怎样看;其三,从空间构造(configuration of spatial construct)的角度,重新思考美术作品配置(assemblage)与所属不同文化的关系。
本书是在比较主义视野下对考古学与艺术史既有研究方法的反思,同时在全球转向的背景下探索着在不同地域间建立对话的可能。贯穿全书的一条重要而有力的线索是对考古类型学的反思,四位学者也分别从不同的角度提出了改进或替代类型学的方法。书中的四篇文章俱以容器为核心,既展现出了其所属地域的历史特殊性及当代研究方法上的不同侧重,也展现出了容器作为人造物的诸多共性,它们暗示着更多联结的可能,为我们更好理解容器提供了重要的参照,同时,在比较之中也深化了我们对地域特性的理解。是近期读到的启发性最大的一本书。 四篇里最喜欢Neer讲希腊容器的一篇,足够多元的材料与足够流动的视野相结合,展现出艺术史这一学科自身最大的魅力之所在。
非常喜欢Claudia写的Introduction本身!也见功力。| 2023:重新读了一部分,当下最喜欢Jas的那篇,前面的描述分析、解释几种解读的路径是细致的准备(虽然也有稍稍飞跃之处,可能是我的具体历史背景不足),为最后一节就器物究竟是否有意涵、有何意涵;emboided subjectivity的古今之辨究竟在哪、是否有必要的讨论做了足够铺垫,精彩。
收藏