Art and Agency

Alfred Gell

出版时间

1998-01-01

ISBN

9780198280149

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Review

This book changes the very basis of the way art has been viewed in the human sciences. It presents what is the first fundamental theory for an anthropology of art. Its publication is a major event. Maurice Bloch, FBA, Professor of Anthropology, London School of Economics. This is a remarkable work ... witty, elegant, broad in its compass and scintillating in its detail. It is characteristically polemical ... alive with his sense of purpose and his quite original and captivating account of how we are captivated by relations between forms ... The book know what to do with the limits of form--one suddenly sees how anthropology might surpass itself. Marilyn Strathern, FBA, Professor of Social Anthropology, University of Cambridge An extraordinary achievement. Gell offers a profound new understanding of collective agency which completely reshapes the anthropology of art, redefines its objects of study, and inspires new conclusions. Caroline Humphrey, Reader in Asian Anthropology, University of Cambridge

Review

"[This] is not only a contribution to anthropology but a subtle and original counterweight to the banalities of globalization theory."--Times Literary Supplement

Reading this book modified my self-image and expanded my understanding of the image-making industry. The text is a little disjointed because it's a rough draft (the author did not live to see it edited or published), but Gell's brilliance and humor are nonetheless transmitted by the book. Hang in there. Although some conflicting portions of the text have since been pointed out ...

(展开全部)

精彩摘录
  • "The position I have reached is that an anthropological theory of art is one which "looks like" an anthropological theory, in which certain of the relata, whose relations are described in the theory, are works of art. But what do "anthropological" theories look like?Can one really give an identificat"
  • "It is important to understand, though, that "patients" in agent/patient interactions are not entirely passive; they may resist. The concept of agency implies the overcoming of resistance, difficulty, inertia, etc. Art objects are characteristically "difficult". They are difficult to make, difficult "
作者简介
Reading this book modified my self-image and expanded my understanding of the image-making industry. The text is a little disjointed because it's a rough draft (the author did not live to see it edited or published), but Gell's brilliance and humor are nonetheless transmitted by the book. Hang in there. Although some conflicting portions of the text have since been pointed out by scholars, Gell's case is solid enough to serve as a springboard for a theory of "understanding" art that could be applicable globally. Who else has done that? The lowest common denominator Gell found looks pretty math-like (we put math models in space capsules because it's a "universal" language), but the book is NOT math-boring. Delightful, eclectic examples illustrate his ideas. I recommend this book for humanities students, artists, art historians and those who are searching for a connection between math and the arts.
目录
Foreword, Nicholas Thomas
1. The Problem Defined: The Need for an Anthropology of Art
2. The Theory of the Art Nexus
3. The Art Nexus and the Index
4. The Involution of the Index in the Art Nexus

显示全部
用户评论
人類學理論主要用來解釋宗教、儀式、族群、婚姻等議題,而Gell本書的貢獻則是他嘗試建立一套理論去解釋“藝術”。在英國社會人類學派傳統下,Gell更關注社會中各元素的關係,於是他建立了Agent和Patience兩大關係,在這兩大關係下又各有index, artist, prototype, recipient四大元素,並檢驗這此元素與元素之間的多重關係,從而幫助我們理解人類學場景中所謂的“藝術”。Gell的邏輯非常清晰,讀的過程中一度有當年讀韋伯《社會學的基本概念》同樣的感覺,很是佩服。
真的厉害,我前天还在问虚构形象能否担当agency呢,gell受我一拜。这样我的《妄代》解析可以着手写起来了呀。
为了写论文读了chapter 7以及Gell的另一篇文章THE TECHNOLOGY OF ENCHANTMENT AND THE ENCHANTMENT OF TECHNOLOGY。可能是我期待过高,希望他也是像Maurice Bloch老爷子一样睛若洞烛。但读下来感觉思想火花时不时能碰到,但不算太多,也是因为不熟悉他举的那些例子。有机会要把全书读下来。
“Friends and colleagues remain painfully conscious of our lost opportunities to debate the issues further with Alfred in person ; yet he has left us with a distributed element of his own personhood, an index of his own creative virtuosity, a gift.”
7.9 External and internal conceptions of agency【internal and external strategies】
算是浏览完了🥵
部分阅毕,盖尔对魔法的解读颇有意思,因果链的过分接近以至于可以逆转。人在空间中的播散也阐发得极妙。external mind对应的intersubjectivity和化用的habitus都颇有见地。相见恨晚。
满满的爱❤️Gell的理论太动人了
收藏