A Commentary on Herodotus Books I-IV (Bks. 1-4) - David Asheri

A Commentary on Herodotus Books I-IV (Bks. 1-4)

David Asheri

出版时间

2007-10-11

ISBN

9780198149569

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Review

"David Asheri, a first-class Israeli Herodotean, who as overall editor of the project has also contributed a lengthy and brilliant, introductory essay on Herodotus and his work. The original Italian version of this essay has now been carefully updated and elegantly translated. For the general reader it, and all four individual books, remain the most valuable and accessible matter in an advanced commentary." --New York Review of Books

"Asheri, Lloyd, and Corcella are exceedingly well-informed concerning the scholarship on the ancient Near East and Scythia produced by those who work in the pertinent sub-fields.... The level of their erudition is breathtaking.... It makes one anticipate with bated breath the publication of the succeeding volume."--Paul A. Rahe, Claremont Review of Books

"Asheri's general introduction...must now be the first port of call for anyone interested in Herodotus: it is distinguished by wide leaning and discriminating judgment and virtually every aspect of Herodotus' work is treated thoroughly and judiciously. Asher's commentaries themselves possess the same qualities.... great benefits to be won from this volume. The editors and their team of translators must be commended.... a volume that should be in the hands of every student and scholar."--John Marincola, Classical World

Product Description

Herodotus, one of the earliest and greatest of Western prose authors, set out in the late fifth century BC to describe the world as he knew it - its peoples and their achievements, together with the causes and course of the great wars that brought the Greek cities into conflict with the empires of the Near East. Each subsequent generation of historians has sought to use his text and to measure their knowledge of these cultures against his words.

This commentary by leading scholars, originally published in Italian, has been fully revised by the original authors and has now been edited for English-speaking readers by Oswyn Murray and Alfonso Moreno. It is designed for use alongside the Oxford Classical Text of Herodotus, and will replace the century-old historical commentary of How and Wells (1912) as the most authoritative account of modern scholarship on Herodotus.

Books I-IV cover the history and cultures of Lydia, Egypt, Persia, and the nomads of Scythia and North Africa, in their contacts with the Greeks from mythical times to the start of the fifth century BC; these themes, with many digressions, are woven into an account of the expansion of the Persian Empire and its relations with the Greeks.

用户评论
补标。我觉得这书没必要翻译吧,能用到的人太有限了。帮助还是很大,不过前四卷的话主要还是各种传说啊地理名物的不那么靠谱的考证……唉毕竟Herodotus,想做得比较细真的不容易。。。
我觉得我离从语言入手来研究历史问题还隔着十万八千里orz
读史难在讳诬,毕竟文本形式的史料归根结底真伪莫辨。考据扎实,对Herodotus的THE HISTORIES文本中的人物、事件、关系进行细致地印证,互联,比对,剖解。自此歧路各别:哪些部分能实锤落地?哪些归于杜撰的传奇?哪些至今仍存疑莫辨?为什么?泾归泾,渭归渭,一一明了。当考古发掘的坚实证据出来以后,再来对历史的尘埃做一番洒扫,其中又有多少不是多余的真实?可惜只注完前四卷,期待随后五卷的注本能付梓。
收藏