Why Read Marx Today? - Jonathan Wolff

Why Read Marx Today?

Jonathan Wolff

出版时间

2003-10-30

ISBN

9780192805058

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

'All too often, Karl Marx has been regarded as a demon or a deity - or a busted flush. This fresh, provocative, and hugely enjoyable book explains why, for all his shortcomings, his critique of modern society remains forcefully relevant even in the twenty-first century.' Francis Wheen, author of Karl Marx In recent years we could be forgiven for assuming that Marx has nothing left to say to us. Marxist regimes have failed miserably, and with them, it seemed, all reason to take Marx seriously. The fall of the Berlin Wall had enormous symbolic resonance: it was taken to be the fall of Marx as well as of Marxist politics and economics. This timely book argues that we can detach Marx the critic of current society from Marx the prophet of future society, and that he remains the most impressive critic we have of liberal, capitalist, bourgeois society. It also shows that the value of the 'great thinkers' does not depend on their views being true, but on other features such as their originality, insight, and systematic vision. On this account too Marx still richly deserves to be read.

Jonathan Wolff is Professor of Philosophy at University College London.

目录
Contents Introduction
Marx's Life and Works
The Plan of this Book
1: Early Writings Introduction
Religion

显示全部
用户评论
拖了两周才读完这本小书。作者删繁就简又有观点地回顾了马克思的理论,真的非常清晰好读。
好读而且爽快!简明介绍了马克思的理论及早期写作,几乎对每一环都提出了质疑。有些质疑刚好是看作者概括理论时,很自然在脑海里产生的疑惑,所以不确定这样概括性的表述其实有没有省略什么关键点,而显得漏洞百出。总之作者认为马克思的理论仍旧是对资本主义最深刻尖锐的批评,不要抱着追求真理和指引的心态去读(如同阅读其他哲学家一样),还是能得到很多启发。但我总觉得这本书应该叫《当今为什么还是不要研读马克思了》(。
系统梳理好评
将来我一定会把它介绍给我的孩子看。
循序渐进,简明扼要,一本入门marxism的佳作。最后的assessment值得一读,但略乏深度。不论认同与否,marx关于anti-capitalism、anti-liberalism的insights都为生活在现代社会的“人”带来了更多反思的可能性,写了很多有关marxism的批评,但想了想还是让它们留在reading note里等待未来被继续修改、深入再make it public吧hhhhh(GV321,不出意外大三一定会选修这门课!)。最简要的总结——我与marx最大的不同是:marx激进且(对human essence,development of history,revolution)乐观,而我激进且悲观。
英美分析哲学传统哺育下的作者真是把清晰明快四个字刻在脑门上了。有继承老师科亨的治学风范,条分缕析、庖丁解牛的本事与辛格那本收录在牛津通识系列里的马克思导论应在伯仲之间。入门马克思,从这两本中任选其一足矣。全书介绍了马克思在早期异化理论、粗线条历史哲学、资本主义政治经济学、未来共产主义社会展望这四大模块的主要思想并分析了各自可取与不足。慧眼独具之处是抓住了马克思对劳动或者创造能力的强调。在纷繁复杂的人性线团中,老马单拈出这根线头,认其作本质与核心,随后庞大理论树干上的各种枝叶花果便都从这一粒种子中自然生发出来了。这就将马克思表述为一个吾道一以贯之而非前后分裂的思想家。然而,一元论者的深刻总是与片面如影随形。例如,如果从人性线团中拈出的不是创造而是性欲这根线头,那又会导向德语思想界的另一个故事。
很好的入门书籍,课业有需要,也是兴趣所在,所以找来看,发现结尾还有推荐书目,更开心了。
新手友好。讲明白了alienation;资本循环;使用价值与交换价值;马克思的历史哲学:economics first model和politics first model的区分很清晰-资本主义社会-共产主义社会不是一个natural evolution
收藏